Sports Asked on January 28, 2021
During the past season or so I’ve noticed in most cases when the ball touches any part of a player’s arm handball is given. Either the handball rule has changed or the introduction of VAR in top tier leagues has impacted what is being called a handball, as these calls almost always result in a couple of minute stoppage for VAR. When such fouls happen the commentators talk about "the new rule", which makes me think maybe the rule itself was modified.
It’s caused numerous goals being taken away and penalties awarded by VAR that would’ve been counted before this rule change.
Most of these handballs are accidental or the players simply didn’t have enough time to react and get their arms out of the way. Not only having goals taken away or goals given (indirectly through penalties) have been impacting games, but sometimes rely on super slow motion shots to look for a handball that totally ignores the athletes’ reaction time.
Yesterday, August 8th 2020, Juventus was given a penalty after the ball hit a Lyon defender on a wall in the arm while his arm is closed and pressed against his body. You can see the foul here.
And today, August 9th 2020, a Messi goal was taken back after VAR ruled it a handball. The ball made a slight touch to his arm after/while he controlled it with his chest. I wasn’t able to see that in the usual slow motion speed. You can see this goal here.
And there was the infamous Lucas Moura handball. Tottenham Spurs Moura was fouled and as he fell a Sheffield United player kicked the ball at his arm, all while Moura is looking away during his fall. The referee plays advantage, Harry Kayne picks up the loose ball and scores with it. But VAR took the goal back cause Moura’s arm made contact with the ball!
I understand by the letter of the law the ball touching an arm is handball, but I don’t see how any of these 3 scenarios could be logically considered as a handball
So has the handball rule has been changed or these handball calls we now see are a byproduct of having video review? If the rule has changed, what was FIFA’s reasoning behind it?
The International Football Association Board (IFAB), which is the body in charge of Laws of soccer, passed a set of rule changes on March 2019 for the 2019/20 season. Some of the main law changes were regarding free kicks, goal kicks, drop balls, and handballs.
So has the handball rule has been changed or these handball calls we now see are a byproduct of having video review?
In short, the rules have changes, and the reasoning behind is to "bring more clarity for handball".
The following are handball rule changes under Law 12:
Deliberate handball remains an offence
The following ‘handball’ situations, even if accidental, will be a free kick:
the ball touches a player’s hand/arm when it is above their shoulder (unless the player has deliberately played the ball which then touches their hand/arm)
The following will not usually be a free kick, unless they are one of the above situations:
So based on the above rules, an accidental handball not a handball, unless it results in a score or a scoring opportunity. So if the ball hits my arm outside of the box accidentally it's not a handball, but if I gain control of the ball, shoot and score, that handball must be ruled a foul. The way I read it, it means a non offencive handball becomes retrospectively a handball in this situation!
However, in April 2020, there was further amendments to handball law:
It is an offence if a player:
Clarification that:
So it seems as of the latest updates, accidental handballs are an offense if they immediately result in a score, but if the ball travels some distance or there are number of passes it's not. The rule is still vague as to what distance the ball can travel, or ho many passes before an accidental handball results in a free kick.
If the rule has changed, what was FIFA's reasoning behind it?
IFAB has the following explanation for the rule changes of the 2019/20 season:
Greater clarity is needed for handball, especially on those occasions when ‘non-deliberate’ handball is an offence. The re-wording follows a number of principles:
The law changes don't mention VAR, but since goal are reviewed by VAR on top tier leagues, these new handball rules are applied with scrutiny.
Correct answer by alamoot on January 28, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP