Sports Asked by Nurp on June 8, 2021
At the 1954 FIFA World Cup, the top two teams from each group advanced to the quarter-finals.
Strangely enough, all four group winners ended up in the same bracket, and the runner-up teams faced each other in the other bracket. This made a dream final between Hungary, Brazil, or Uruguay impossible, and eventually helped group runner-up West Germany reach the final more easily.
Why was this decision taken?
Looking at a decent number of articles about the 1954 world cup, none of them talk about why the tournament had the strange format. Some only mention the format and note how strange it was comparing to current-day format. But that being said, the format is strange to us because we've had a format that hasn't changed much in many years and is very symmetric.
Let's take a look at the previous tournaments:
So although the 1954 tournament had a weird format, there had been no agreed upon format yet. All world cups till then had a strange format with today's standard. The hosts and FIFA were still trying to figure out a "fair" format. Traveling was much harder back in the day - think of having teams travel to Uruguay back in 1930! Also as the tournament gained more and more popularity, and with the rise of broadcasting, having more matches and teams to increase revenue became a goal for the organizers.
Nonetheless, the format was criticized, eventually leading to a format we currently have.
All that aside my guess is the mentality was that the best team should win the tournament, regardless of the format. If I had to speculate why the knockout stage of the tournament was held that way, these are what I can think of:
It guarantees blockbuster match ups
It makes knockout matches more intriguing
It exhibits higher fairness for weaker teams
Answered by alamoot on June 8, 2021
It's not true that the group-winners ended in the same bracket. Instead, Group1 played against Group2 and Group3 against Group4:
This is pretty much the modus of modern FIFA World Cups (since 1982). So the reason there was no "Dream Final" like Brazil-Hungary was that Brazil ended up second in their group. The weird thing about the 1954 World Cup was the first stage, where two teams in each group were seeded and did not need to play each other. This lead to repeated games in the first round (West Germany vs Turkey and Switzerland vs Italy). This was supposed to make sure the seeded teams advance more likely to the next round. I agree with the other answer that it took FIFA a long time to figure out a decent mode.
Answered by E. Sommer on June 8, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP