TransWikia.com

Why was Arcanine with the Legendary Birds in Veridian City in Pokémon Origins?

Science Fiction & Fantasy Asked on August 14, 2021

In Pokémon Origins, Red sees a image with the three legendary birds and Arcanine.

enter image description here

Why was Arcanine there? I mean, he’s ‘The Legendary Pokemon’ but not a legendary Pokémon. In this question/answer, there is a comment by Rayz Rusher on the answer that Arcanine was originally a legendary Pokémon:

“…Nintendo first gave Zapdos, Articuno and Arcanine as the legendary trio. But they removed Arcanine as it would have been awkward. Two birds and a dog, huh!…”

This still does not add up because Pokémon Origins was created a while after they removed Arcanine. Any thoughts?

4 Answers

In a much earlier episode of the Pokémon anime, Ash goes to the same Pokémon center in Viridian City and sees the same picture. This must be just a callback to that, which was much closer to when Arcanine was still considered a legendary Pokémon by Gamefreak and Nintendo.

Chicken menu in 2nd episode Image from 2nd episode of Pokemon Anime - Bulbapedia article.

Correct answer by Firestrike2000 on August 14, 2021

I had read a theory which described Arcanine as being a legendary for a type of Pokémon that was scrapped all together, being “Beast” type. It was supposed to include second gen Pokémon like Houndoom and such, but they got pushed to Gen 2 and made "Dark". If this is true, my take and theory on it all is that Arcanine was supposed to be a legendary for the beast type which was eliminated, and I feel it would explain why Moltress is still present, as well as why the backgrounds for the two legendaries being different (they would represent different types). Because they scrapped that type of Pokémon, Arcanine was a legendary Pokémon of a type that no longer existed. Subsequently his type would’ve been changed from “Beast” to “Fire” and the legendary Fire type Pokémon was already Moltress. A "Beast" type Pokémon would explain also how Arcanine, a fire type, is more physical-stat oriented than special-stat.

Answered by Kspliff on August 14, 2021

Arcanine was always meant to be a legendary Pokémon. It would replace Moltres when designing the game. But Game Freak decided it was too weird to have two birds and one dog. However, many easter eggs or errors were left. Such as in the second pokemon anime episode where Arcanine can be seen with the legendary birds. Then There's one in the Pokémon Trading Card Game: I found in one of my old Arcanine cards: It says Legendary Pokémon as an easter egg. And also the one from the episode on origins is an easter egg.

Answered by Eduardo Miranda Mapelli on August 14, 2021

(Not including real life things like Nintendo and changes etc.)

Maybe there WAS a beast type, but Pokémon trainers didn’t like the extra type with only one Pokémon (at the time) so they decided just to merge Arcanine into the fire type, but since there was already a fire type legendary Pokémon they just decided to wipe it from the legendary list, making it no longer legendary.

But before all that happened they made the “plaque” or whatever you want to call it. Than people over time forgot that Arcanine was legendary THOUGH it was still mysteriously called “the legendary Pokémon”.

Also something I’ve heard is that each bird represents a different season but not autumn so maybe Arcanine would represent autumn.

Answered by April on August 14, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP