TransWikia.com

Why aren't Earth humans considered Species 001?

Science Fiction & Fantasy Asked by iMerchant on April 7, 2021

In the book trilogy, Star Trek: Destiny, the Borg are first created when two injured, dying, and slightly deranged Caeliar unnaturally merged/assimilated two humans that were with them when their ship crashed in 4527 BCE as a means of survival. Humans from the 22nd century had inadvertently came across the highly advanced and xenophobic Caeliar. An accident ensued, and a few humans and Caeliar got slung back in time on the other side of the galaxy.

The newly formed Borg’s devastating, insatiable appetite continued on from there until the Borg were finally taken care of in 2381 AD/Stardate 58100 (about 16 months after the events of Nemesis).

If the Earth humans are the first ones to be assimilated, why aren’t they Species 001 (or 002/003 depending on how/if the Caeliar/Borg are catalogued)?

6 Answers

Maybe they were known as Species 001 or 002 (as Caeliar should be 001) at that time (5th millennium BC) and we just do not know.

But you have to understand that this was the first iteration of the Borg Collective. As per Star Trek Voyager episode 6x07, "Dragon's Teeth", we find out that during the 15th century AD the Borg controlled only a handful systems and the Borg memory from before that time itself is fragmentary. So we can postulate that the numbering currently in use (in the 24th century) must originate from a time after. By the time the 2 human drones must have died off and as such humans gained a new designation when encountered anew.

Correct answer by Martin Handrlica on April 7, 2021

From startrek.com:

As a rule of thumb, the events that take place within the live-action episodes and movies are canon, or official Star Trek facts. Story lines, characters, events, stardates, etc. that take place within the fictional novels [...] have traditionally not been considered part of the canon.

Therefore the events of this book series don't fit in with the TV series because they're not canon. There's no need for any other Star Trek works to acknowledge or be consistent with this version of the Borg's origins.

Answered by OrangeDog on April 7, 2021

The Borg were first introduced in the "Q Who?" episode of STNG. During a conference is the following dialog:

PICARD: Guinan, how much more can you tell us about these creatures?

GUINAN: Bits and pieces.

PICARD: Anything would help.

GUINAN: They're made up of organic and artificial life which has been developing for thousands of centuries.

http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/142.htm[1]

Thus it seems that the Borg first became cyborgs hundreds of thousands of years ago.

Could the Borg have been a more recent combination of organic and mechanical elements that had been been developing separately for hundreds of thousands of years before combining recently? NO! it took billions of years for the first multicellular life to develop on Earth and hundreds of millions more for the first intelligent life to evolve. It would be impossible for the biological component of the Borg to evolve tens of thousands of times faster than Earth life.

The writer of Star Trek: Destiny obviously forgot to check "Q Who?" to see what it said about the origin of the Borg. If he had he would have seen that his origin date of

4527 BCE

was falsified.

The same is even more true for the popular fan theory that the Borg were created as a result of Voyager VI/V'ger encountering the machine Planet.

Answered by M. A. Golding on April 7, 2021

The memory of the Borg being fragmented before 900 years ago is canon and is stated in the Voyager episodes dealing with the Vudwaar by Seven of Nine!

As for Q's stated origin date of 4527 BCE, as Q would say, "Oh, you're assuming linear temporal progression, how quaint!" We need to know how Q defines 'origin' and also keep in mind that the Borg are a combination of both technological and organic components and a good degree of assimilation.

Answered by DefinatelyNotQ on April 7, 2021

I haven't read Star Trek: Destiny but I'm going to leap into this here:

The creation of the Borg was not a planned event. For all intents and purposes, it just happened.

Survival was the first priority. Expansion -- by assimilating other species -- came later. It was at that point numbering was introduced, starting with species 001 as the first species assimilated from that point forward.

Answered by born2code on April 7, 2021

As a huge fan of Destiny, here's my take on the numbering system. Since the Caelier was badly degraded when she merged with the two humans, it is possible that no memory existed from any of the three. Therefore, Species 001 would be the humanoids that were assimilated when they came to explore the island, that were native to that world.

Answered by user131896 on April 7, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP