TransWikia.com

What "Space Rangers" does the TNG writers/directors guide refer to?

Science Fiction & Fantasy Asked on August 11, 2021

The Star Trek: The Next Generation Writers/Directors Guide from 1987 mentions in its "What doesn’t work" section (emphasis by myself):

  1. Treating deep space as a local neighborhood. Too often, script ideas show characters bouncing from solar system to solar system, planet to planet, without the slightest comprehension of the distances involved or the technologies required to support such travel. Fine (and even fun) on SPACE RANGERS but not on STAR TREK.

Let me say that I think this rule/wish was pretty much ignored as the series went on (for what it’s worth, this applies to various of the items in the "What doesn’t work" list). "Bouncing from solar system to solar system" is exactly what Star Trek crews tend to do in some episodes, and Star Trek certainly has its examples of writers "without the slightest comprehension of the distances involved" (warning, TVTropes link).

That notwithstanding, what does the mention of "SPACE RANGERS" allude to?

  • Is it a reference to some concrete work named "SPACE RANGERS", just like "STAR TREK" in the same sentence? If so, which one? I only know one short-lived show of that name, but it’s from 1993 and thus probably wasn’t yet in the making back in 1987. The Disambiguation page on Wikipedia doesn’t list any other candidates of that name that would really fit, either.
  • Or is the term "Ranger" just meant to evoke a certain generic idea among the presumed U.S. American readers of the document? (One that is still so specific as to match the description in the paragraph? So far, "ranger" usually made me think of vast and sparsely populated areas than a "local neighbourhood", but then, I do lack the right cultural background to know that word in context 😉 )

2 Answers

While there was eventually a show in 1993 called Space Rangers (It did not survive competing in the same space as DS9 and Babylon 5). I'm quite certain you are correct that this is meant to invoke an idea with people of a certain cultural background. They could have just as easily said generically "GALAXY QUEST".

Prior cultural examples would be "Lone Ranger" [Edit as Star Trek was originally competing with TV Westerns and followed the same format - just in space.] and Tom Corbett Space Cadet [Edit - I actually should have said Rocky Jones Space Ranger here - but it doesn't matter that show is not particularly significant as the word Ranger is generic western stuff]. Star Trek being originally a "Wagon Train" to the stars.

Addendum: By creating a made up strawman tv show to compare itself to with a similar title - the Star Trek bible is elevating itself above what a cheap copycat show would do. It "treks" according to the physics of that universe. The copycat show "ranges" at the speed of plot. In reality of course Trek has an very mixed record on that front. But compare how much JJ trek changed speeds to instantaneous just serve the plot - that is the point it was trying to make

Answered by lucasbachmann on August 11, 2021

Under the circumstances, I believe the writer may be referring to the TV serial 'Rocky Jones, Space Ranger', a syndicated science fiction TV serial from the 1950s.

This show is a perfect example of planet-hopping adventure with no real worldbuilding conception of how travel in space would actually occur.

Answered by Valorum on August 11, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP