Science Fiction & Fantasy Asked on April 16, 2021
I’m confused by the reasoning why the crew of the Enterprise were only looking for two pairs of boots.
I mean there’s the assumption here that the two crew members beamed back to the Enterprise and not the hidden Bird of Prey.
In which case if the crew were only looking for someone who altered the logs of the photon torpedos, then there wouldn’t have been any boots.
Spock's dialogue suggests that the recovery of the boots was vital, not merely to determine whether Gorkon's assassins came from the Enterprise or not, but in order to identify the guilty parties, and subsequently prove Kirk's innocence:
SPOCK: Any progress?
VALERIS: None. We have a crew of three hundred turning their own quarters inside out, but the killers may still be among them. Surely they have disposed of these boots by now. Would it not have been logical to have left them on Gorkon's ship?
SPOCK: Even logic must give way to physics. Gravity had not been restored by the time they escaped. Without the boots, they would have floated off the Klingon transporter pads.
CHEKOV: Why not simply vaporise them?
Valeris takes a phaser from a storage unit on a nearby wall.
VALERIS: Like this?
Valeris fires the phaser, vaporizing a pot. Alarms howl for a few seconds, before Valeris silences them by flipping a switch on the same wall.
VALERIS: At ease. As you know, Commander Chekov, no one can fire an unauthorised phaser aboard a starship. ...Suppose when they returned they threw the boots into the refuse?
SPOCK: I'm having the refuse searched. If my surmise is correct those boots will cling to the killers' necks like a pair of Tiberian bats. They could not make their escape without them, nor can they simply throw them out the window for all to see. Those boots are here, somewhere.
SPOCK: Ah! Mister Scott, I understand you're having difficulty with the warp drive. How much time do you require for repair?
SCOTT: There's nothing wrong with the bloody thing.
SPOCK: Mister Scott. If we return to Spacedock, the assassins would surely find a way to dispose of their incriminating footwear, and we will never see the Captain or Doctor McCoy alive again.
SCOTT: Could take weeks, sir.
SPOCK: Thank you, Mister Scott.
It's true that he couldn't be certain the boots were on the Enterprise, and that the only thing he knew for sure is that someone on the Enterprise altered the ship's data banks to indicate that two torpedoes had been fired. The notion that the assassins had beamed from Gorkon's ship to the Enterprise was therefore only a working theory at this point, as acknowledged in subsequent dialogue:
SPOCK: Klingon blood.
CHEKOV: They must have walked through it when it was floating and tracked it back here.
SPOCK: This is the first evidence that corroborates our theory.
But since the recovery of the boots was apparently the only means of proving Kirk's innocence, it made sense to search for them on the Enterprise in the hope that they could be found, rather than assuming that they were beyond effective reach on a cloaked Bird-of-Prey somewhere (where they could've been destroyed already), in which case the investigation would've been dead in the water.
Correct answer by LogicDictates on April 16, 2021
From the original script.
CHANG: You crippled our gravitational field with a direst torpedo hit, and two Starfleet crewmen beamed board in magnetic boots and did this! WE HAVE WITNESSES!.
This information was conveyed to Spock. Since he knows that the Enterprise was sabotaged after the beam-out, it seems logical that the assassins would have beamed back to the Enterprise after carrying out the attack, still wearing their boots.
Chekov's expression remained puzzled. "I do not understand. If there was a ship underneath us, surely the assassins beamed aboard from that vessel, not Enterprise. his
"You have forgotten something," Spock told him.
"The data banks claim we fired. If we did, the killers are here; if we did not, whoever altered the data banks is here. In any event, what we are searching for is here."
Chekov's frown deepened. "What are we searching for, Mr. Spock?" He turned toward Yaleris, certain that she understood-in her studies, she had excelled in logical deduction. "Tell him, Lieutenant."
She straightened self-consciously in response to his scrutiny. "Two pairs of gravity boots."
Admittedly there could be a third saboteur/assassin on the ship, but logically we don't introduce new postulates unless there's a reason to do so.
Answered by Valorum on April 16, 2021
I’ve since thought of a possible reason, but I’m not entirely happy with it.
It could be that they were looking for boots to prove that the 2 crew did come from the enterprise. Or that all boots were accounted for without Klingon blood and therefore the 2 crew didn’t come from the enterprise.
However, neither of these help in the matter of logs. Indeed it seems likely or possible that the female Vulcan officer would have altered the logs.
Answered by Jules on April 16, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP