Science Fiction & Fantasy Asked on August 13, 2021
There’s a Stephen Fry vs. JK Rowling story that periodically memes up:
Just after the first Harry Potter book had been released, [Fry] was offered the role of narrating it for audiobooks. He hadn’t read it, and was simply told it was a children’s book, so figured it would be an easy afternoon’s work. When he met JK Rowling, she mentioned that she was writing a sequel. Stephen replied very condescendingly “good for you”.
A few years down the line, the books are selling well, and he is doing the recording for the Prisoner of Azkaban, when he runs into the phrase “Harry pocketed it”. Stephen could not say this line. It always came out as “Harry pocketeded it”, unless he said it ridiculously slowly. They tried time and time again to get it right, but to no avail. Eventually, he called up JK and asked if he could say “Harry put it in his pocket” instead. She thought for a moment, then said “no”, and hung up.
The phrase “Harry pocketed it” appeared in the next four books.
There’s a video (Facebook) where Fry confirms the main part of this. Is the final sentence true?
Good story, but it isn't true! @stephenfry wasn't condescending, he was completely lovely, and that phrase isn't in 4 books! #factsmatter
Original answer below.
Book 4: "Harry pocketed it"
He pulled Sirius’s reply off Pigwidgeon’s leg, Harry pocketed it, and they hurried back to Gryffindor Tower to read it. (Chapter 23)
Book 5: "pocketed it"
'Right-o,' Fred said brightly, spraying the Doxy quickly in the face so that it fainted, but the moment Mrs. Weasley's back was turned he pocketed it with a wink. (Chapter 6)
Book 6: "pocketed it"
Not long after this, Hagrid became tearful again and pressed the whole unicorn tail upon Slughorn, who pocketed it with cries of, “To friendship! To generosity! To ten Galleons a hair!” (chapter 22)
Book 7: No pocketing :-(
Note: While the question was only asking about the accuracy of the finale part, it should be noted that the phrase Harry pocket it is not found anywhere in The Prisoner of Azkaban, nor for that matter is the word pocketed.
Harry pocketed it - 4 times
"Better get the cloak," Ron muttered, as Lee Jordan finally left, stretching and yawning. Harry ran upstairs to their dark dormitory. He putted out the cloak and then his eyes fell on the flute Hagrid had given him for Christmas. He pocketed it to use on Fluffy -- he didn't feel much like singing. (PS16)
"Well, it's not much use to you," said Ron. He dropped his voice. "Fifty points if you can get it through Myrtle's nose."
Harry, however, pocketed it. (CS13)Mr. Diggory handed Harry his wand and Harry pocketed it. (GF9)
He pulled Sirius’s reply off Pigwidgeon’s leg, Harry pocketed it, and they hurried back to Gryffindor Tower to read it. (GF23)
Pocketed it - 2 times
'Right-o,' Fred said brightly, spraying the Doxy quickly in the face so that it fainted, but the moment Mrs. Weasley's back was turned he pocketed it with a wink. (OP6)
Not long after this, Hagrid became tearful again and pressed the whole unicorn tail upon Slughorn, who pocketed it with cries of, “To friendship! To generosity! To ten Galleons a hair!” (HBP22)
Pocketed - 4 times
"We're going to talk now," said Riddle, still smiling broadly, and he pocketed Harry's wand. (CS17)
Each wore an expression of utmost contempt, yet the unexpected entrance of so many witnesses seemed to have brought them to their senses. Snape pocketed his wand(, turned on his heel)1 and swept back across the kitchen, passing the Weasleys without comment. At the door he looked back. (OP24)
He looked at Ron. "You saved everything because you felt lucky. You did it all yourself."
He pocketed the potion again. (HBP14)Then he returned to the Gaunt hovel, performed the complex bit of magic that would implant a false memory in his uncle's mind, laid Morfin's wand beside its unconscious owner, pocketed the ancient ring he wore, and departed." (HBP17)
By book:
Philosopher's Stone - 1 occurrence, He [harry] pocketed it
Chamber of Secrets - 2 occurrences, including Harry(, however,) pocketed it.
Prisoner of Azkaban - No occurrences
Goblet of Fire - 2 occurrences, both of which are Harry pocketed it.
Order of the Phoenix - 2 occurrences, including pocketed it.
Half-Blood Prince - 3 occurrences, including pocketed it
Deathly Hallows - no occurrences
Supplementary works - no occurrences
Interviews - no occurrences
Pottermore - no occurrences
1 ", turned on his heel" was removed in later editions.
Correct answer by ibid on August 13, 2021
Stephen Fry describes exactly this scenario in this video, right down to the condescending "good for you" remark.
https://twitter.com/bbcarts/status/1133060526920142848
Stephen Fry does offer a potential explanation for why Rowling said no, from 2:30 in the video.
[…] she [J. K. Rowling] had wanted the audiobook to be complete, unabridged, not condensed in any way as sometimes audiobooks are. Because she felt that if children are reading it and listening at the same time, they would be annoyed if it was different. So it was very important that we got it exactly right.
So...at least according to Fry, this story is accurate (though it's worth noting that he states that the phrase "appears in every subsequent book", so either he is mistaken or exaggerating for effect).
Answered by DavidS on August 13, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP