TransWikia.com

In "Girl Genius" novel "Agatha H. and the Clockwork Princess", do the Van Rijn Muses contain human consciousnesses?

Science Fiction & Fantasy Asked on January 11, 2021

In Girl Genius, there were nine super-intelligent robot "Muses" that were made by the spark van Rijn for the Storm King.

They are robots, but they can hold a human consciousness, as they did for both Lucretia and for Tarvek’s sister (I forgot her name).

Given their challenging relationship with the first Storm King, especially their disinclination to his marriage to the Heterodyne, and their unilateral inability to advise him against his own destruction, they could be said to exhibit the irrational behavior of humans attached to him. It is arguable that divination using the cards, as done by Moxana, is not a clank thing but a consciousness thing.

Question: Are they actual humans put into the constructs by Van Rijn? Are they full clanks, or are they a consciousness + clank cyborg?

One Answer

There's too much we don't know about the Muses to answer fully.

Let's discuss your thoughts first.

"Anevka", the robot clank that Tarvek's injured sister operated, was a learning machine that adapted to how it was used, and didn't even realize the original Anevka had died at some point during her operation. Tarvek built it himself, based on what he learned from studying the Muse Tinka. Lucrezia also used this same clank, albeit by getting downloaded into an improved head Tarvek had built.

This suggests Muses either can host or can mimic human minds... but doesn't really prove it, given the tech is Tarvek's, "Anevka"'s lack of self-awareness, and Lucrezia's lack of... well, anything resembling humanity. Does make it pretty likely.

Second, we absolutely know that minds - synthetic or organic - can be transferred.

Lucrezia's studies under Castle Heterodyne made concrete that minds could be transferred. Lucrezia was able to transfer the original muse Otilia's clank mind into the organic (mostly) construct Von Pinn, and then transferred the Heterodyne Castle AI mind into Otilia's clank body. Note however, her work isn't without effects, intentional or otherwise. Otilia-in-Von-Pinn's mind was a few fries short of a happy meal by the time of the story, probably not helped by being beholden to Lucrezia's control voice which the Von Pinn body had built in. There's also a really giant question mark about if the Castle AI got forced into Otilia's body, whether or not that was relevant to what the hell happened that wrecked Castle Heterodyne to begin with - which definitely broke whatever mind was left in the Castle.

In addition, we have a hearsay confirmation at a point you haven't read yet -

Finally, the Muses themselves.

  • Moxana. There seems to be very little point to Moxana's lack of speech. Sure, it forces her metaphoric communication to be more effective, fitting her role. But if Van Rijn's clanks truly were original creations meant to be a pinnacle of form... where exactly did the idea of being mute come from? None of the others were, and the ones we've seen weren't meant to be great orators.
  • They did serve the Storm King, but were built to inspire him to greatness, not purely to obey him. ... pretty sure it didn't work. All spoiler at this point.

Correct answer by Radhil on January 11, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP