TransWikia.com

Lawbreaking by the numbers

Puzzling Asked on December 9, 2020

Special Agent Benford has been stymied by a third unsolved case of
miscreant creative accounting and will voluntarily retire
from the Fraudulent Numbers Task Force.
Benford’s ability to detect falsified ledgers by merely
counting the first digits of numerical entries is so renown that a
law bears the name of our crestfallen hero.

Benford’s Law: 
On an honest accounting sheet,
the first digit of almost 1⁄3 of all numerical entries
should be ‘1’,
much more often than ‘2’ or any other numeral.
The count of each numeral’s being a first digit
fits a decreasing pattern
where ‘9’ is the first digit of the fewest numbers.

This methodology served Benford well through decades of service
as unscrupulous accountants mostly juggled
decimal numbers.
Over the years, however, two cases remained uncracked because
they involved other numbering systems.
All positive whole numbers are suspect.

  1. Unsolved Case One.
    Recognizing the oldest known numbering system,
    Benford knew that its first digits would not lead to conviction.

  2. Unsolved Case Two.
    Benford recognized this numbering system
    as one employed by virtually all modern computers
    and again had to admit that its first digits were free of clues.

At last, alas, came the latest case.

  1. Unsolved Case Three.
    Benford had never before encountered this numbering system
    but upon seeing the entries
    realized that they too would defy “The Law.”
    Before giving up, Benford did learn that
    the same deviant numbering system had been seen
    among scholarly circles for centuries,
    though rarely, and has actually been the basis of
    some cleverly efficient digital computers.

What are the numbering systems of Cases One, Two and Three
and why are they so Lawless?

Bounty challenge:
In which of these cases can
Benford’s replacement, Special Agent Successor,
be more successful by counting entries’ second digits?
What would be their expected numeral frequencies?


(No foul wordplay is afoot.)

One Answer

I think the answer is as follows.

Case One:

Case Two:

Case Three:

Bonus:

Correct answer by Jeremy Dover on December 9, 2020

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP