TransWikia.com

Why isn't the capillary tube displaced downward by the column of water?

Physics Asked on May 17, 2021

Water moves upward in a capillary tube due to intermolecular forces between water and the glass wall of the capillary tube.

If those forces act on water pushing it up, why don’t we see the opposite effect (water forcing the walls of the tube down, due to Newton’s third law)?

I know this is not a paradox, I am just looking for the correct description as to why we don’t see this effect.

One Answer

We do. The walls of the tube are pulled down. However, virtually in all meaningful situations, the tube is sufficiently anchored such that this small force is undetectable. It just gets transferred onto the ground/table/etc.

However, were you to do this experiment in zero-gravity, and expose an open tube to a drop of water, you would indeed see that the water moves one way, and the tube moves the other way. The end result would be that the center of mass of the water/tube did not change.

Hypothetically, if you put the tube on some hyper-sensitive crush washer which was calibrated to crush just over the force the empty tube applies, you would find that adding water crushes the washer. The water would be pulled up, and its mass would be supported by the tube, and thus supported by the washer.

Correct answer by Cort Ammon on May 17, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP