Physics Asked on April 28, 2021
Classically, a system of noninteracting electrons restricted to move in 2D will execute circular motion in an external magnetic field $perp$ to the plane. But in quantum analysis, the same noninteracting electrons in the same situation gives rise to equispaced harmonic oscillator levels, called Landau levels. Why should harmonic oscillator levels arise out of the blue? Is there a relation between classical circular trajectories and quantum harmonic oscillator levels?
Why should harmonic oscillator levels arise out of the blue?
Edit after reading new comments: if you write down the Hamiltonian of the system using the standard minimal coupling of the momentum $vec{p} to vec{p} + q vec{A}$ and you write down $vec{A}$ for a uniform magnetic field using the gauge that you prefer, you get exactly the Hamiltonian of a harmonic oscilator. You should not be surprised, cause circular motion is a two-dimensional harmonic motion!
Is there a relation between classical circular trajectories and quantum harmonic oscillator levels?
Yes! The classical motion of a particle of mass $m$ and electric charge $q$ in an external magnetic field $B$ is given by Newton's second law: $$ m frac{v^2}{r} = q v B ;;; rightarrow ;;; r = frac{mv}{qB}. $$ Let me write this radius in terms of kinetic energy $E=frac{1}{2}mv^2$, which is more convenient for comparison with quantum motion and let me write $r^2$ rather than $r$: $$ r^2 = frac{2mE}{(qB)^2}. $$
Now in quantum mechanics you can prove that the energy eigenvalues are $$ E_n = frac{hbar q B}{m} left( n + frac{1}{2} right), $$ where $n$ is a non negative integer labeling the levels; and the corresponding wave function is $$ psi_n(x,y) = N_n (x + iy)^n e^{-qB(x^2+y^2)/4hbar}, $$ $N_n$ being a normalization constant.
Now if you compute the expectation value of the operator $r^2 = x^2+y^2$ you get the following result $$ leftlangle r^2 rightrangle = frac{2hbar}{qB} ( n + 1). $$ You can compare the classical result with the quantum result at high energies, so you can assume $n gg 1$ and simplify $ leftlangle r^2 rightrangle approx frac{2hbar n}{qB}$, and similarly $E = frac{hbar q B n}{m}$. If you combine these two results to get rid of $n$, you immediately get $$ leftlangle r^2 rightrangle = frac{2 m E}{(qB)^2}, $$ which is exactly the classical result!
Correct answer by Matteo on April 28, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Answers
Recent Questions
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP