Physics Asked by Jeffrey Suen on November 24, 2020
Forces like the electric force has a Coulombs constant $k_e$ from the Coulomb’s law
$$
F=k_efrac{q_1q_2}{r^2}
$$
, which is based on the vacuum permittivity $epsilon_0$. However, the magnetic force can be directly calculated from the scales of charge, velocity and magnetic field strength in SI units by Lorentz law.
$$
mathbf F_{mag}=Q(mathbf vtimesmathbf B)
$$
Is it because the unit for magnetic field is derived from the Lorentz law in SI units? If so, why can’t the unit of charge or electric field be derived from SI units of distance and time just like magnetic field?
The answer to your question was correctly highlighted by jacob1729: you don't see a constant in $F_{m}$ because you are writing it in terms of the field $B$, and you're seeing it for $F_e$ because you're writing it using the charges. If you rewrite
$vec{F_e}=k_efrac{q_1q_2}{r^2}hat{r}=q_1vec{E}$
you absorbed $k_e$ (therefore $epsilon_0$) into $E$.
But one may ask: can I do the opposite? Can I rewrite $F_m$ to make $mu_0$ appear? Yes, but not in the same way. There are different ways to write $B$ depending on the setup, for example Biot-Savart law for solenoids, but as far as we know you can't find a formula like
$vec{F_m}=k_mfrac{g_1g_2}{r^2}hat{r}=g_1vec{B}$
because there isn't a magnetic charge.
Correct answer by Mauro Giliberti on November 24, 2020
This expression is about a charged particle moving through a medium with some speed. For the movement of the charged particle, any solid medium is out of question. Only the liquid and gaseous medium remain. If you choose to ignore the drag force, there is no change in speed due to the medium. Now there is only one factor that the medium can influence and that is the magnitude of external magnetic field. So, whatever the source of magnetic field (either a current carrying conductor or a permanent magnet) that is present in the given situation, its field will depend on the medium. And therefore the term of permeability will be in the expression for this magnetic field.
Answered by Pramod on November 24, 2020
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP