Physics Asked on April 25, 2021
As a scenario let’s take a box filled with air in empty space and no gravitational field around. As the box is opened,the air inside will rush outside and the box will move in opposite direction because of Newton’s third law of motion but what is exactly pushing the box or where does the force coming from?
Before the box is opened, air molecules are bouncing off of every surface of the box. Let's focus on the surface with the door (call it the "front" wall), and the opposite surface (the "back" wall). Molecules bouncing off the front wall exert a force on the box in the forward direction, but these forces are balanced by molecules bouncing off of the back wall.
When the door is opened, molecules simply escape through the door and no longer bounce off the front wall. Therefore the forces due to molecular collisions on the back wall are not compensated by collisions with the front wall, and there is a net backwards force on the box.
Correct answer by Andrew on April 25, 2021
As Andrew’s answer says, when you make a hole in the wall of the box it does not create a new force - it is the removal of the pressure on this part of the wall that makes the forces on the box unbalanced and so the box moved in the opposite direction.
Another way to think of this is that conservation of momentum tells us that the centre of mass of the box plus the air that it contained cannot accelerate (since there are no external forces). But as the air escapes in one direction its own centre of mass accelerates, so the box must accelerate in the opposite direction to conserve momentum.
Answered by gandalf61 on April 25, 2021
As the box is opened,the air inside will rush outside and the box will move in opposite direction because of Newton's third law of motion
Andrew and gandalf61 posted some great answers, but neither (directly) addressed Newton’s third law (gandalf61 did mention conservation of momentum, which is related).
Newton’s third law says that whenever an object A exerts a force $mathbf{F}$ on an object B, B exerts a force $-mathbf{F}$ on A. That is, Newton’s third law is about pairs of forces. But none of the posts so far mention any pairs of forces.
Let’s introduce one. But we won’t look at air molecules, because they are too difficult to study individually. Instead, we can consider all the air molecules collectively as a single object. The other object is the open box.
As the other answers have established, the air pushes on the back of the box. This means that the box is pushing on the air, in the opposite direction – towards the front – with the same magnitude of force. If the air is lighter, then it will have a greater magnitude of acceleration, which results in a greater magnitude of velocity, which balances with the lower mass to result in the same magnitude of momentum. If the air is heavier, the same ideas apply, with everything reversed.
The previous paragraph shows how Newton’s third law is related to conservation of momentum, as mentioned in gandalf61’s answer.
It should also show how Newton’s third law, by itself, doesn’t really explain anything. Phrases like the one in your question suggest that the writer misunderstands this law; hopefully this answer will clear that up.
Answered by Brian Drake on April 25, 2021
The conservation of momentum (as discussed in answers by others) applies considering the entire fixed mass consisting of the box and the mass of air moving into (or out of) the box. Considering the box and its contained air alone, you need to be careful as this a system of variable mass if the mass of air inside the box changes. The Halliday and Resnick Physics tests provide a simple discussion for systems of variable mass.
A rocket is another example of a system with variable mass.
From a thermodynamics point of view, a system with variable mass is an "open" thermodynamic system (one with mass transfer in/out). See one of the Sontagg and Van Wylen textbooks on thermodynamics.
Answered by John Darby on April 25, 2021
What is pushing the box is the rushing air.
If you somehow removed the whole box at one moment the air would still rush, but what would there be to push?
If you pierced all six sides of the box at once, you might see the same result.
Answered by Robbie Goodwin on April 25, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP