TransWikia.com

What is Tsirelson's bound for the original bell's inequality

Physics Asked on May 1, 2021

As its well known, quantum correlations break Bell’s inequalities only to a certain limit called the Tsirelson’s bound. The bound was written for the CHSH inequality.

My question is what is the Tsirelson bound for the original case that Bell dealt with in his article, and how it is proven.

2 Answers

The folklore says the upper bound is 3/2 but I don't remember a reference. I am going to reproduce some old notes of mine demonstrating that bound.

First, Bell's original inequality is eqn (15) of [1]:

$$1+P(vec{b},vec{c})ge|P(vec{a},vec{b})-P(vec{a},vec{c})|,$$

where $a,b,c$ are unit vectors. The associated quantum prediction is obtained by using eqn (3) which states that

$$P(vec{x},vec{y})=-vec{x}cdotvec{y}.$$

So the quantum version of the inequality can be written

$$underbrace{|vec{a}cdotvec{b}-vec{a}cdotvec{c}|+vec{b}cdotvec{c}}_{displaystyle R}le 1.$$

Your question would then be how badly $R$ can violate that upper bound of 1. By a suitable choice of basis, we can always write

$$begin{align} vec{c}&=(cosvarphi,sinvarphi,0), vec{b}&=(cosvarphi,-sinvarphi,0), vec{a}&=(cosphisintheta,sinphisintheta,costheta), end{align}$$

with $varphi,phiin[0,2pi]$ and $thetain[0,pi]$.

Then

$$begin{align} vec{a}cdotvec{b}&=cos(phi+varphi)sintheta, vec{a}cdotvec{c}&=cos(phi-varphi)sintheta, vec{b}cdotvec{c}&=cos^2varphi-sin^2varphi, end{align}$$

and

$$R=2|sinvarphisinphisintheta|+1-2sin^2varphi.$$

This is a second-order polynomial in $|sinvarphi|$ whose maximum is reached for $|sinvarphi|=frac{1}{2}|sinphisintheta|$ and the maximum value is $frac{1}{2}|sinphisintheta|+1.$ This latter bound is then maximum for $phi=theta=pi/2$ and the maximum value is $3/2$. It is therefore reached for $varphi=pi/4$.

[1] John S. Bell. On the Einstein Podolsky Rosen paradox. Physics, 1(3):195–200, 1964. (pdf)

Answered by user154997 on May 1, 2021

Tsirelson's bound for CHSH works only with matrix sum. If one uses Kronecker sum instead then the eigenvalues are -4,-2,0,2,4. So the average of CHSH can reach 4 in tensor quantum mechanics.

Answered by Cretin2 on May 1, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP