TransWikia.com

What is the specific derivation of the speed changes in the two equations from which Einstein originally inferred the relativity of simultaneity?

Physics Asked by Timm on December 20, 2020

The two specific equations I’m asking about were stated at an introductory stage in the famous 1905 paper which launched Special Relativity. He didn’t explain how this derivation was arrived at; all I wish to understand is what his direct explanation would have been. The equations were:

$t_B – t_A = r_{AB}/(c – v)$

$t^*_A – t_B = r_{AB}/(c + v)$

These equations referred to a light ray emitted from $A$ at time $t_A$ and then reflected back from $B$ at time $t_B$, returning to $A$ at time $t^*_A$; where $A$ and $B$ are the ends of a rigid rod in a state of linear inertial motion, measured at velocity $v$ relative to its prior state of inertial motion. In this prior state its length was measured as $r_{AB}$. The times referred to were measured by observers located with clocks co-moving with locations $A$ and $B$ at velocity $v$; these clocks had been synchronised with those established as measuring the time on the rod prior to its state of motion changing to $v$. These events all occurred in empty space where the universal speed of light was assumed always to measure as $c$.

I ask my question about how $c – v$ and $c + v$ are derived for the equations above because, given Einstein’s two postulates, the following pair of equations would seem more appropriate:

$t_B – t_A = r_{AB}/c$

$t^*_A – t_B = r_{AB}/c$

The equivalence of these latter equations would of course have demanded a very different conclusion.

One Answer

For the sake of clarity, suppose that in the world reference frame, the rod is moving to the right with velocity $v$, and $A$ is to the left of $B$. Also, let $r'_{AB}$ be the length of the rod in the world reference frame (shorter than in the rod reference frame due to length contraction).

The first two equations you listed refer to the world reference frame. For example, we have $$t_B - t_A = r'_{AB}/(c - v)$$ because the light ray travels with velocity $c$ and $B$ travels with velocity $v$. Similarly, $$t^*_A - t_B = r'_{AB}/(c + v)$$ because the light ray travels with velocity $-c$ and $A$ travels with velocity $v$.

The latter two equations you listed refer to the rod reference frame. This demonstrates relativity of simultaneity because in the rod's frame, light would take the same amount of time to go both directions. This is not true in the world reference frame.

Answered by invjac on December 20, 2020

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP