TransWikia.com

What causes the bucket to launch in the air?

Physics Asked by Glowingbluejuicebox on February 13, 2021

In this video potassium is dropped into the bucket and it reacts with the water present in the bucket causing an explosion within the bucket itself.

I don’t see how an internal explosion makes the bucket launch up vertically in the air. If anything it should press harder on the ground.

6 Answers

Relevant XKCD.

Unusually for an exploding-potassium demonstration, this one uses a potassium sample attached to a weight. This causes the potassium to sink to the bottom of the bucket, where it generates and ignites hydrogen gas. This creates a temporary bubble launching the water upwards and the bucket downwards. The bucket's motion gets blocked by the table, but the water is free to rise. The bubble quickly cools and collapses, and air pressure pushes the bucket upwards towards the rising water.

Correct answer by Mark on February 13, 2021

It does press hard on the table surface. There are two possibilities here.

If you watch closely, it almost appears like the bench has a spring loaded mechanism which gives the container a rapid lift at the point of the reaction. This is could have been done for “theatrical effect”.

Another possibility (and more likely) is that when the reaction takes place, the rapid ejection of gas and chemicals upwards will cause the container to press downward causing a depression in the surface of the table. Then very quickly the table then retains its original form (think about compressing a spring then letting it go) and causes the container to rise rapidly.

But you were correct to point out that it makes no sense for the container to shoot directly upward as if the reaction provides some form of vertical thrust, which it obviously should not given that the chemicals themselves shoot upwards and not downwards.

Edit: It has been pointed out in comments by others who slowed the video down to a frame/second and pointed out that the surface of the bench remains deformed for a short time after the container leaves the bench.

Another possibility (perhaps the best) is that as the reaction happens, this caused the sides and bottom of the container to expand rapidly. The outward bulge therefore on the bottom of the container caused by the rapid expansion of chemicals and gases, causes it to launch itself because this expanding bulge pushes off from the surface of the bench.

Answered by joseph h on February 13, 2021

I am not particularly satisfied with the answer of Dr jh.

the table is still deformed downward when the bucket is lifted off of the table. there is a coaster(?) on the table that the table has been pushed below, but has yet to rise back to push it up, and, when it does, the item while much less massive than the bucket of water is not launched as high.

the explosion pushes water away from its source. this force also pushes against the table, but because the table is solid and attached to the earth it does not move (much) and instead accelerated the bucket up.

If a spring is compressed into a table then released, the spring expands about its center of mass putting force into the table. Since the table doesn't move, the spring rises from the table. The same thing is happening here.

Answered by John Meyer on February 13, 2021

A very general answer would be Newton's third law of motion,as a result of the explosion , a force is applied on the ground , an opposite force is then applied on the bucket by the earth so it launches it into the air.this is as simple as it can be explained , but a more rigorous answer can be given.

Answered by Jalaleddin El Firqi on February 13, 2021

The explosion stretches the side of the container. As a ball widens as you push it down, so does the structure of the bucket,only opposite. It's height shrinks. It wants to relax. It does so, and in doing so must lift off the table. It is accelerated, and no force acting against it except the puny air resistance.

Answered by Stian Yttervik on February 13, 2021

The bucket jumps just like you do: by suddenly extending the lower extremities. The flat bottom of the plastic bucket is not completely rigid, and bulges outward suddenly when pushed by the explosion.

It is only by having this “leg” that can move separately from the rest of the bucket’s “body” that the jump is possible; if the bucket were replaced by a sturdy glass jar, I would not expect much of a jump—rather, the water would spew upwards leaving the jar on the table.

Answered by Ben51 on February 13, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP