TransWikia.com

They say the universe is expanding. Is that the same as saying that time is contracting?

Physics Asked by Roger Wood on January 15, 2021

Apparently the distance between galaxies used to be smaller in the distant past. That means it used to take fewer units of time to get from one galaxy to the next. So either the distance really was smaller in the past or the units of time used to be bigger in the past.
Which of the following is true?:

  1. The spatial dimensions of the universe are expanding
  2. The time dimension of the universe is contracting
  3. The distinction between #1 and #2 is meaningless
  4. The question illustrates my complete ignorance of general relativity.

    (I fear the answer is #4, so some intuitive guidance would be helpful)

2 Answers

They say the universe is expanding. Is that the same as saying that time is contracting?

No.

  • First, to measure time we employ means that are independent of the large scale behavior of the universe. In particular, the second, SI unit of time, is defined via the transition frequency of caesium atom and not through e.g. the duration of light-speed trip to Caelum Supercluster.

  • Second, the expansion of the universe is not homogeneous on smaller distance scales. Small scale objects such as atoms or even planets and even larger gravitationally bound systems such as galaxies and galactic clusters keep their size. It is the space between galactic clusters that is expanding. See e.g. this question for the discussion.

So OP's list item 1 is true, list item 2 is false, and list item 3 is also false precisely because there are scales of time and distance that are independent of large scale cosmological behavior. As for item 4, asking questions is how we learn.

Answered by A.V.S. on January 15, 2021

1-3 are all true.

  1. If you use the most common cosmological coordinates, in which position is scaled by a factor $a(t)$ that increases with time, then the coordinate distance between galaxies is constant but the measured distance increases because of the scaling.

  2. If you use conformal coordinates, in which both position and time are scaled by $a$, then the coordinate distance is constant and the coordinate speed limit (speed of light) is constant, but clocks tick faster at later times so it takes more real time to get to other galaxies.

  3. Coordinates are meaningless. It takes longer, in actual measured time, to get between the galaxies at later times because they're getting farther apart, in actual measured distance. How you model this with coordinates and "scaling" has no bearing on those physical facts.

I guess 4 is also true, but you've gotta start somewhere. Understanding that coordinates are meaningless is the first step to understanding GR.

Answered by benrg on January 15, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP