Rutherford scattering experiment, part 1

Question

Around 1906-1914 several classical experiments on scattering of $alpha$-particles on gold and platinum foils have been performed by Rutherford, Geiger, and Marsden.  In standard literature on the subject it is tacitly assumed that the atoms of gold and platinum remained at rest after the interaction with $alpha$-particles.

My question is why it is the case, particularly what was known at the time of experiments? Was it known at the time that atoms of gold (or platinum) interact with each other and form a crystal lattice?

Jon Custer · Accepted Answer

First, while your textbook may assume that the target atoms remained at rest (it makes the math easier), Rutherford, Geiger, and Marsden knew how to do the full kinematics problem and did not assume that. For gold and platinum it makes almost no difference in the analysis since those elements are ~50x more massive than an $alpha$ particle (He ion).
Second, crystallography had a long history before then, and x-ray diffraction was demonstrated in 1912 (see Wikipedia on that), so, yes, scientists such as Rutherford and his group would have been reasonably sure that their targets were polycrystalline at the least. Still, Rutherford scattering results do not depend on the target being crystalline - crystals, amorphous, liquid, or gas targets will show similar scattering of the $alpha$ particles.

Rutherford scattering experiment, part 1

One Answer

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question