If an elevator and its shaft were weighted, would they weight less as the elevator goes up?

Question

I have a question that would probably be easy for you.
If we could put an elevator together with its shaft on a scale and have its motor pull it up, lets say for 50 floors.
will the reading on the scale be less while the elevator is traveling?
I'm not talking about fluctuations that will be caused by inertia as it's starting to move, I'm talking about the weight while the elevator is being pulled up steadily.
I tend to think that it will stay the same but on the other hand I also think that the motor at the top pulls it up like a force that uses energy that objects gravity and might make the scale read less while it pulls?
Or maybe because it's slow it will weight the same and if it would've been pulled up "as fast as a rocket" the elevator will be "weightless" for a few seconds?
I didn't study physics but I'm curious.

hdhondt · Accepted Answer

I'm talking about the weight while the elevator is being pulled up
steadily.

If the elevator is travelling at constant speed in a constant gravitational field, then its weight will stay the same while it's travelling. However, as it moves upward, it is getting further from the centre of the earth. Hence the earth's gravitational attraction is reducing as it travels up. As weight (a force) is the product of mass and gravitational acceleration, it's weight (not its mass) will reduce as it travels up.

S. McGrew · Answer

While the elevator is accelerating upward, which means that its speed upward is increasing, the shaft, elevator, motors, pulleys, etc., will weigh more. If the elevator falls with no resistance from the mechanism, the whole assembly will weigh less; but if the elevator's fall is slowed by a braking system the whole assembly will weigh more.

Answered by S. McGrew on July 8, 2021

If an elevator and its shaft were weighted, would they weight less as the elevator goes up?

2 Answers

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question