Physics Asked by Abhijeet Singh on April 27, 2021
Landau-Lifshitz Mechanics says that there are $2s-1$ constants of a system with $s$ degrees of freedom (beginning of the second chapter on Conservation Laws). If this is true, for a single free particle moving in 3D space, there should be $5$ constants of the motion. However, I can just count $7$ of them: three components of linear momentum, three components of the angular momentum, and the kinetic energy. What is wrong here?
Landau and Lifshitz distinguish between constants of motion and conserved quantities--the former being mere mathematical results of integration and the latter being profound statements regarding unchanging quantities in physical systems (energy, momentum, etc.). The $2s-1$ quantity is a count of the former.
For a free particle, its motion can be given by $vec{x}(t) = vec{x}_0 + vec{v}t$, where $vec{x}_0$ is the position when time $t=0$ and $vec{v}$ is the velocity. There are six constants of motion: three in $vec{x}_0$ and three in $vec{v}$. However, this is, in a sense, over-specified since time does not explicitly occur in the equations of motion (i.e., the original Lagrangian). Choosing another initial position, $vec{x}(t) = vec{x}_0' + vec{v}t$ results in the exact same motion as long as $vec{x}_0' = vec{x}_0 + vec{v}k$ for some value of $k$. The space of constants that don't make a difference is parameterized by a one-dimensional scalar $k$, so the space of constants of motion that do make a difference and are independent is reduced by one.
Since a translation in time is an unimportant transformation (time is homogeneous, so the choice of what $t=0$ means is arbitrary), we can create a constant of motion associated with the choice of the initial time coordinate $t_0$, leaving $2s-1$ constants that depend only on the position and velocity coordinates ($q_i$ and $dot{q}_i$ for $i in 1, 2, ... , s$ in the textbook notation). The latter set of constants contain all of the interesting physics.
Here's an example of a set of five ($2s-1$ where $s = 3$) constants of motion that completely define a free particle:
These five numbers define the motion of the particle unambiguously in a timeless way.
Answered by Mark H on April 27, 2021
It's true there are 7 conserved quantities. But for a free particle begin{equation*} E=frac{1}{2}mdot{mathbf{q}}^{2}=frac{mathbf{p}^{2}}{2m} end{equation*} so $E$ can be written in terms of $mathbf{p}$. So we have now 6 conserved quantities. The other relation you need is $mathbf{p}cdotmathbf{L}=0$ where $mathbf{p}$ is the linear momentum and $mathbf{L}$ is the angular momentum, which implies that one component of them can be expressed in terms of the others. So the independent conserved quantities are back to 5.
Answered by Simo on April 27, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Answers
Recent Questions
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP