Can Unruh particles be blocked on their way from the horizon?

Question

Can you shield yourself from Unruh particles? In an old answer to a different question, Ron Maimon says yes:

You should think of the radiation as coming from the horizon--- if you place a refrigerated barrier between you and the horizon, you won't see any radiation past the barrier (at least not until it heats up). The reason is that the temperature of the barrier at the end furthest from the horizon forms the boundary condition for the Rindler Hamiltonian [...] and if it has a very long period in imaginary time, so does all the spacetime further along the Rindler x coordinate [...].

The barrier in his setup accelerates with you. What if it's inertial? For example, suppose there's a barrier suspended below you by a rope which you then cut. Does it instantly become transparent when it starts to fall toward the horizon? It seems that it must – it can't absorb the particles without continuing to heat up, and an inertially moving object in a vacuum can't heat up. But it's hard to believe that Unruh particles are similar enough to ordinary radiation that they seem to travel from the horizon to you, but different enough that they choose whether to interact with a solid object or completely ignore it based on the second derivative of its position.
Another possibility is that Ron Maimon is wrong and the particles don't travel from the horizon, but that seems no better. It would seem to imply, for instance, that if you're near a glowing black hole, you can't block the glow by closing your eyes, in stark contrast to ordinary blackbody radiation which seems to closely resemble Hawking radiation otherwise.
What really happens, and why isn't it as crazy as it looks?

Chiral Anomaly · Answer

For Unruh radiation, the typical wavelength is comparable to the distance to the horizon, because both quantities are determined by the acceleration. Contrast this with Hawking radiation, for which the typical wavelength is determined by the size of the black hole, even if the distance from horizon to observer is much greater than the size of the black hole.
I don't know what Ron Maimon meant by "You should think of the radiation as coming from the horizon," but notice his comment below that answer:

...the typical wavelength is about the distance to the horizon, so it is hard to establish direction of motion on the radiation...

A more general way to say this is that the typical wavelength is determined by the acceleration. For a quantitative example, consider an object with an acceleration of $a = 100$ km/s$^2$. That's an intense (bone-crushing!) acceleration by everyday standards, but the corresponding Unruh "radiation" still has a typical wavelength of $sim c^2/asim 10^{9}$ km.
Can it be shielded? Well, introducing any additional material into the scenario will change the conditions and therefore possibly change the phenomena. The important point is that Unruh "radiation" can equally well be regarded as a local effect, as local as anything with such an enormous wavelength can possibly be. Introducing new material whose distance from the object is less than the wavelength can certainly have an effect regardless of the direction of the "radiation," so it's not clear to me that there is any paradox.

Andrew Steane · Answer

A good way to calculate the Unruh effect is to do the calculation in an inertial frame. In that case it becomes a way of discussing the interaction of an accelerating detector with the ordinary Minkowski vacuum.
If a mirror is fixed in an inertial frame then it only makes a modest change to the vacuum state of the field so I think it does not destroy the Unruh effect for detectors accelerating away from the mirror. If the mirror is accelerating with you, on the other hand, then it makes a substantial change to the vacuum state and then I don't know the outcome but I suspect the Unruh effect may then vanish.
This paper is helpful in this context:
Quantum optics approach to radiation from atoms falling into a black hole
Marlan O. Scully, Stephen Fulling, David M. Lee, Don N. Page, Wolfgang P. Schleich, and Anatoly A. Svidzinsky PNAS August 7, 2018 115 (32) 8131-8136; https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1807703115

Can Unruh particles be blocked on their way from the horizon?

2 Answers

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question