TransWikia.com

Can lightly-ionized atoms be accelerated to relativistic speeds with current technology?

Physics Asked on December 7, 2020

I know there’re lots of various particle accelerators, which can accelerate particles to TeV’s of energy, but it seems they all work on electrons or nuclei or other elementary or tightly-bound particles.

Is it possible, using current technology, to accelerate lightly-ionized atoms, like e.g. $text{Ca}^+$ to speeds of the order of $frac34c$? If yes, then is it done somewhere? If no, what are the limiting factors?

Apart from just possibility to accelerate, would such ions be left intact after acceleration? Or would the accelerating field strip off or considerably excite some of the remaining electrons?

3 Answers

In relativistic heavy-ion collisions, you're usually interested in reactions with much higher energy than the kilo-eV scale of a few dozen bound electrons. A typical RHI collision will have something like 10,000 particles in the final state, so a few dozen bound electrons in the initial state won't make much difference either.

What does make a difference is the charge-to-mass ratio. A massive, charged particle in an electric field will have an acceleration $a$ that obeys $$ F = ma = qE,quadtext{or}quad a = Efrac qm. $$ By "stripping" all the electrons from a nucleus you get a much larger $q/m$, and so you get more energy per ion for the same electric field $E$. That's what the high-energy, quark-gluon plasma folks are after.

However, there are other applications where you might want a singly-ionized nucleus — for instance, to use for atomic or molecular spectroscopy, perhaps loaded into a Penning trap. In that case, between your ion source and your accelerator you have to have some magnetic steering of the beam, which separates the beam by species with different $q/m$. If you went to a nuclear structure laboratory and asked for a beam of singly-ionized calcium at $frac34c$, they would probably say "calcium-40? -44? -48? or one of the rare or unstable calciums?"

Searching the web for "ion beam spectroscopy" finds

  • an old review article which says that "fast ion beams" typically have energies of 10–105 eV.

  • at the recently-closed Holifield rare-isotope accelerator an ion spectroscopy facility "… with negatively- as well as positively-charged ions … of exotic nuclei like, e.g., 79Cu and 85Ga … [at] energies of about 200 keV." This facility was probably for nuclear spectroscopy, rather than electronic transitions, but the inner-shell electrons in heavy atoms are fast and can have a big effect on nuclear properties.

  • a recent conference proceeding describes spectroscopy of a $lambda approx 600,mathrm{nm}$ transition in Ar+ ions in a 20 keV beam.

The argon-ion beam should appeal to your interest in special relativity. The ion beam wasn't dramatically relativistic, having $gamma-1 = frac{text{kinetic energy}}{mc^2} approx frac12times10^{-6}$. But the transition frequency was measured with a precision ${Deltanu}/{nu} approx 6times10^{-10}$. A change in beam energy of 1 eV, about one part in 104, changed the frequency of the resonance by nearly fifty times the experimental uncertainty. This is the power of precision experiments, that there are complementary ways to access the stranger corners of the world: by going there directly, where the strange effects are obvious, or by looking very carefully where the strange effects are subtle. The argon-ion paper has some very interesting references.

Correct answer by rob on December 7, 2020

The (average) mass of the Calcium ion $text{Ca}^+$ is around $m_{ca} = 40 amu = 40 times 1.661 times 10^{−24} g = 66.44 times 10^{−24} g$.

That means that to accelerate (from rest) an ion of Calcium to a speed of $frac{3}{4}c$ the energy needed would be:

$$Delta E_{ca} = (frac{1}{sqrt{1-(frac{3}{4})^2}}-1)m_{ca}c^2 = 0.512m_{ca}c^2$$

which is around (taking $c=299792458 m/s$):

$$Delta E_{ca} = 3.057 mu Joules$$

Now, assuming that the CERN LHC accelerator is the current state-of-the-art in particle accelerators/colliders. The LHC can provide energies in the range of 0.64 microjoules to 92.0 µJ (per particle) depending on type of particles.

As one can see from the previous crude approximations, the acceleration (even to half the speed of light) of (a sufficient amount of particles of) ionised Calcium is out of the ability of current state-of-the-art technology.

Per an error in getting the correct calcium mass and the context of @ACuriusOne's answer. The acceleration of calcium ions is within the range of the LHC collider.

Answered by Nikos M. on December 7, 2020

Not only can it be done, it is being done at several facilities. See e.g. http://alicematters.web.cern.ch/?q=lhc-heavy-ion-program-begins. LHC trumps RHIC's energy by orders of magnitude. It can accelerate heavy ions to 2.76 TeV per nucleon pair, compared with RHIC’s 200 GeV. Since a nucleon has a rest mass of approx. 1GeV, these nuclei are highly relativistic.

Having said that, they are not accelerating Ca, but e.g. lead and gold, i.e. much heavier nuclei.

Answered by CuriousOne on December 7, 2020

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP