Physics Asked on April 8, 2021
I was recently wondering why the field force between two objects is proportional to the square root of the distance (sometime you just take things for granted). This comes from the inverse-square law, in which fields are treated as field lines (started wondering why is that the case, but decided to take this for granted) and the "square" comes from the relation between the area of a sphere and its radius. Makes sense. This, however, made me ponder 1) if all fields must follow this law; 2) if in theory fields can be collimated in analogy to light beams (lasers)? After all doesn’t QM allow for field particles or are these just useful but completely abstract mathematical creatures? I can’t imagine how gravitons can be particles if gravity is a time-space distortion. What are your thoughts on the possibility of field beams and if there are fields that don’t obey the $r^{-2}$ rule?
PS
I’m not a physicist nor a fanatic fan of Star Wars (haha), just a fellow scientist from a different field.
This is really just a pedantic detail, but only forces between monopoles fall off as $1/r^2$. For example the force between two electric dipoles falls as $1/r^3$, the force between two electric quadrupoles as $1/r^4$ and so on.
This detail aside, the obvious example of a force that does not obey the inverse square law is the strong force. The reason this happens is that the strong force is mediated by gluons, but gluons carry a colour charge so they interact with each other. Contrast this with the electromagnetic force, which is mediated by photons that are not charged and do not interact with each other. This means that with the strong force we do indeed get "force beams" of the sort you are thinking of. These "beams" are called flux tubes or QCD Strings, and as a result of the tube formation at long distances ("long" here means > $10^{-15}$ metres) the strong force between two particles bearing a colour charge tends to a constant value instead of an inverse square dependence.
While it isn't really in the spirit of your question, we can see flux tube formation and a non-inverse square behaviour even in electromagnetism when the field is propagating in a medium. For example if magnetic fields are propagating in a plasma then the fields interact with the charged particles in the plasma and again we can get flux tube formation and a non-inverse square behaviour.
Answered by John Rennie on April 8, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Answers
Recent Questions
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP