TransWikia.com

Invest on real state vs other option

Personal Finance & Money Asked by Guillermo on August 27, 2021

I own half of a house that I rent out. I paid 20K and the current value of the house is 70K – 75K (so roughly 35K is mine).
The current state of the house is poor and a rent on the current condition is impossible.

I have 2 options

  1. Get a loan of 65K to bought the other half and fix the house for a rent of 4.5K after taxes a year.
    Total invest of 85K. I will need 20 years to get the money back.
    After 20 years I will get a 100K house and the money back

  2. Sold the house I will get 35K on my 20K. And I could invest the 35K in a 10% a year rate.
    After 20 Years without taking any cash out I will get 180K Cash

This is not my home, this is an investment.

2 Answers

Never have business partners. IMO dump it and take your money.

Answered by Fattie on August 27, 2021

So this is a pretty straightforward IRR problem with some unknown variables.

You have an asset that you can sell for 35K (forget what you paid for it - that's a sunk cost. You claim that you could invest it for 10% elsewhere - presumably with a similar level of risk as the rent house.

So that 10% would be your required rate of return. You would compare that to the rate of return on the house based on the cash flows.

I can already tell you that you won't get a 10% rate of return on the house, since the rent alone is only giving you a 5.3% return (4.5 / 85) and you haven't even considered the interest expense on the loan or other expenses like maintenance/taxes/insurance. If you're paying 3-4% on interest you might be lucky to break even. Yes, you'll have an asset that's appreciating in value, but unless that appreciation is 20% or so annually it wont get you to 10%.

But, for the sake of argument, you would take all of the cash flows in each year (initial 65K outlay, rent income, interest and other expenses, and sale value of the house after 20 years), plug them into excel or a financial calculator, and calculate the "IRR". If the IRR is less than the 10% you can earn on other investments of similar risk, then it's not as good of an investment.

Answered by D Stanley on August 27, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP