TransWikia.com

Can you "expenses-in-a-corp V. standard deduction" in the USA?

Personal Finance & Money Asked on September 1, 2021

This seems like a "too good to be true" tax dodge in the USA milieu.

Is it correct?

  • Sally is a graphic designer married with a typical family. She gets $100,000 in 2017 as 1099 income.

  • She buys a Graphics Monitor in 2017 for $1000. We’ll say, it is genuinely and absolutely a true and honest deductible expense for her work/clients. (She bought it for "a particular job" so the entire amount is deductible at once.)

  • She files her taxes. She gets the "standard deduction" of $12,700. So it’s completely pointless itemizing deductions.

  • In short she gets $12,700 deductions.

She goes back in time and tries this:

  • She has an S-Corp (or LLC as an S-Corp). It is paid the $100,000 in 2017.

  • The monitor is a deduction, a cost, for the S-Corp. Which thus profits $99,000 in 2017.

  • Sally gets $99,000 income, and takes the standard deduction of $12,700.

  • In short she gets $13,700 "deductions".

This appears to be an absolutely correct way to save 1000- in taxable income.

Any deductions (more precisely: "costs") totaling under 12700 in situation "A" are totally wasted; in situation "B" you get them.

It seems too good to be true – am I correct?


Just a clarification for any future googlers, in fact I am not correct. IE, there is no advantage, you "get" the $1000 either way. HartCO explains it below!

2 Answers

Business expenses (deductions) offset business income, so no matter which type of pass-through business entity she is using (Sole proprietorship,LLC,S-Corp,Partnership), the expenses will offset her business revenue. She's taxed on the profit from her business, not the revenue.

In both cases, she only has $99,000 in business income reported in the income section of the 1040, and nothing further down on her tax return changes that. The only tax-disadvantage she faces filing as a sole-proprietor (example 1) is that she might pay more self-employment tax than if she has an S-Corp.

Correct answer by Hart CO on September 1, 2021

It goes on Schedule C, which is business profit/loss, and has no impact on itemized deductions.

Answered by eSurfsnake on September 1, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP