TransWikia.com

Use a shortest-paths argument to prove a combinatorics identity

Mathematics Asked by walterman on January 16, 2021

Let m and n be nonnegative integers, and let r, s, and t be nonnegative integers such that $r + s + t = m$. Use a shortest-paths argument to prove that:
$$binom{m+n}{n}=sum_{a,b,c} binom{r+a}{a}binom{s+b}{b}binom{t+c}{c}$$

2 Answers

This graphical representation of a typical staircase pattern in a $n times m$ rectangle:

enter image description here

shows 3 boxes, here represented in red, black, blue, the nature of which we are going to explain using natural coordinates conventions.

How are these boxes determined ? By the fact that each staircase pattern reaches the first level at $y=r$ for a certain $x=a$; in the same way, level $y=r+s$ is reached for a certain $x=a+b$, giving intermediate points with coordinates

$$(a,r), (a+b,r+s) $$

(otherwise said, $a$ is determined by $r$, $b$ is determined by $s$...)

Together with endpoints with coordinates $(0,0), (n,m)$, we have all the diagonal "corners" of the 3 boxes attached to the staircase pattern.

Let us now partition the set of staircase patterns into classes $C_{a,b}$ having the same 3 boxes. Each such class being composed of the concatenation of any staircase pattern in the different boxes, we are in a multiplicative context and

$$Card(C_{a,b})=binom{r+a}{a}binom{s+b}{b}binom{t+c}{c}$$

elements. As it is a partition, it remains to sum all these products to get the total number $binom{m+n}{n}$ of staircase patterns.

Correct answer by Jean Marie on January 16, 2021

Recall that you can interpret ${n + kchoose n}$ as the number of lattice paths from $(0, 0)$ to $(n, k)$ while only moving north or east. In addition, each of these ${n + kchoose n}$ paths are all shortest paths because we always move one unit closer to the destination. Also, you need to use the fact that subpaths of shortest paths are also shortest paths (otherwise, we could just take a shorter subpath to make the entire shortest path even shorter).

Now interpret ${m+nchoose n}$ as the number of shortest paths from $(0, 0)$ to $(m, n)$ while moving only north or east. Interpret the three terms in the sum as subpaths of the shortest path.

Answered by Ekesh Kumar on January 16, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP