TransWikia.com

Why is "Martenot" in “ondes Martenot” capitalised but not “theremin”?

English Language & Usage Asked by ipso on March 18, 2021

Usage including that in the respective Wikipedia pages shows "Martenot" in "ondes Martenot" and "theremin" are capitalised differently.

Léon Theremin developed the theremin in 1918, and Maurice Martenot invented the ondes Martenot in 1928. "Ondes" is “waves” in French.

Why does one keep the capitalisation of its creator’s name but not the other?

One Answer

Vaguely:

  1. Theremins are slightly better known than ondes Martenot. Not being capitalised is the norm for English words, and like pebbles in a river words lose unusual features the more they are used. A similar thing often happens with genericised trademarks (those who call all vacuum cleaners hoovers regardless of manufacturer, would normally not capitalise it).
  2. The name ondes Martenot more clearly refers to its manufacturer. Even if one didn't see immediately that Martenot was a surname, one would wonder "waves what?" and then learn this was the case. Conversely, one might not realise that theremin came from the westernised form of the name Termen / Терме́н.
  3. Of the various names first used for theremins, all were lower-case, and some included its inventors name (whether the Westernised Theremin or the more directly transliterated Termen); thereminophone, termenvox, thereminvox. From the various suggested names (along with ætherphone in a few spellings), the final name theremin was arrived at less directly from Theremin than was ondes Martenot from Martenot.

I say "vaguely" because there's no hard and fast rule about how these things will turn out, though in this case the last point made the lack of capitalisation on theremin particularly likely.

Correct answer by Jon Hanna on March 18, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP