TransWikia.com

Why are there multiple kinds of dashes in the English language?

English Language & Usage Asked by Minnow on April 25, 2021

At our writing disposal are a preponderance of short straight lines:

  • Hyphen –
  • En dash –
  • Em dash —
  • minus sign −
  • Horizontal bar ―
  • Figure dash ‒

From what I’ve read, the em﹘ and en−dashes—in particular originated with typography. What is not clear to me is why so many variations were they created. This post–which makes a case against using them‐suggests that the em-dash itself is of nebulous origin―at least in terms of time.

Usage has been covered on this site and others (e.g. When should I use an em-dash, an en-dash, and a hyphen?) , but ‑where did they all come from and why the need for so many short straight lines?

2 Answers

If you look at printing manuals from the mid-19th century (you can find these on Google books, for example Typographia: Or, The Printer's Instructor, from 1857) there wasn't any distinction between em-dashes and en-dashes when used as punctuation.

This book recommends using em-dashes—with no spaces to either side—to set off parenthetical comments, and also using em-dashes for ranges of numbers, like 33—47.

Printers also had dashes available in twice, three times, four times, and maybe six times the length of the em-dash (called a two-em dash and so forth), as well as the en-dash which was half the length of the em-dash. These were intended to be strung together so as to create horizontal rules of arbitrary lengths.

————–

At some point, I assume that some printer decided that en-dashes—which were readily available because of their use for horizontal rules—looked better than em-dashes for ranges of numbers, e.g. 33–47. Other printers copied him because it did indeed look slightly better. This became enshrined as a tradition, and now standard English punctuation has two lengths of dashes, when one length would serve nearly as well, as it did in the 19th century, and be less confusing.

Correct answer by Peter Shor on April 25, 2021

Those are printer's conventions. (In printer's lingo, an "em dash" is a dash the width of a capital M, and an "en dash" is a dash the width of a capital N.) Functionally, a hyphen divides a word by syllables (and may link words in a phrase to form an adjective), the minus sign indicates an arithmetic operation, and the rest are punctuation. If you were using an old-fashioned monospaced typewriter, you would type the hyphen and the minus sign as one dash and the rest as two dashes.

The distinctions are not linguistic, and each style book will take its own position.

Answered by Bob on April 25, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP