TransWikia.com

Which noun was referred to after comma?

English Language & Usage Asked on December 15, 2020

I am reading a paragraph in English. English is obviously not my first language. I like to confirm my understanding of a sentence.

This is the sentence.

Copernicus had offered his replacement for the old Ptolemaic
astronomy, moving the sun to the center of the solar system and
letting the Earth, now just one of a number of similar planets, circle
round it.

In the sentence, “moving the sun to the center of the solar system and …..” refers to “replacement” not “the old Ptolemaic astronomy”.

Am I right? Could you tell me which one it is referring to?

3 Answers

Your question isn't easy to answer, as you have written it.

But the Ptolemaic astronomy put the Earth at the centre of the universe, and assumed that everything else rotated around it.

Copernicus decided that the planets orbited around the Sun, not the Earth.

Answered by Simon B on December 15, 2020

Here is how I would interpret your sentence:

Ptolemaic astronomy considered Earth the center of the universe. What the sentence is stating is that Copernicus determined that the sun was the center of the solar system, and therefore Earth was not the center (or the most important) planet in the solar system, and that Earth was one of several planets orbiting the sun.

Answered by Jennifer S on December 15, 2020

It is appositive to "Copernicus". It says that Copernicus was moving the sun, etc. Given the context, it also communicates that that this was the result of offering his replacement. So it can be seen as modifying "offered"; it's saying "Copernicus had offered his replacement for the old Ptolemaic astronomy, and in offering his replacement, he moved the sun". "moving" is not referring to "replacement", as it's characterizing the action (verb) of "offer", not the thing (noun) of "replacement", and it's definitely not referring to "the old Ptolemaic astronomy".

Answered by Acccumulation on December 15, 2020

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP