TransWikia.com

When an action is not carried out, who is the subject?

English Language & Usage Asked by ImaginedElement on April 6, 2021

“My mother gave me money.”

My mother is the subject, money is the direct object, and I am the indirect object who receives the money.

“My mother did not give me money.”

This sentence states what my mother did not do. Because she did not act, there was no direct object for me to receive. Is my mother’s inaction the topic of the speaker (me)?

I’m not an English buff (just letting that be known). Thanks.

EDIT: Thank you all for clarification. I am definitely blending philosophy with features of language and I think what I’m getting at is better suited for the philosophy site.

One Answer

You are confusing the effect of the sentence with the meaning of the sentence. No matter whether an action takes place or not, how the parts of speech function in the sentence do not change. In this case, "My mother did not give me the money," the direct object is still money and the indirect object is still me.

Answered by FeliniusRex on April 6, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP