English Language & Usage Asked by Dmytro Shun on September 11, 2020
I am a non-native speaker of English and therefore need your help. The question is: why do we use the zero article in the phrases “a change of X” and “a switch from X to Y”?
For instance:
a change of address
a change of government
a switch from student to teacher
The words following the prepositions set in bold (that is, address, teacher, student, and government) are all countable nouns, are not they?
So why do they get to be used without an article given that they are countable nouns?
How are they different from a change and a switch, which do have an article before them?
To my knowledge, the article, noun and proposition “a change of” does not restrict your grammar choices for government.
An indefinite mass or plural noun does not require an article. If you are using the noun government as an indefinite mass noun (i.e. referring to the essential nature of government or the condition of having government [what you mean by “generic way]) then you choose not to use an article – also called choosing the zero (null) article or zero-marking. Avoiding further specificity by not adding an article forces you to consider the essential nature of the thing the noun names.
The following are all grammatically correct:
And so are:
These are all grammatically correct and have different meanings.
I also made a switch from of to in because in works better with all these other variations. But let’s consider that difference as well.
These two sentences use government as an indefinite mass noun, which means we are mainly concerned with the governance of the country. The sentence with in implies that an internal change of the current government is acceptable, such as a change in foreign policy. The sentence with of implies that the current government needs to be replaced by a new government (through election, coup or revolution) to achieve the change of government we ultimately want.
Answered by lukejanicke on September 11, 2020
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP