Whatever: pronoun, conjunction or determiner?

Question

I have already learned what is the general difference between conjunctions and conjuncting pronouns, and that is the fact that a pronoun can be a subject or an object in the clause whereas a conjunction can not. But it seems, there are still exceptions like "whoever" and "whatever".
So, in the sentence below "whatever" is certainly a pronoun. Here, the dependent clause is a noun clause.

You are free to do whatever you want.

But in the next sentence, which contains adverbial clause, "whatever" seems to be a conjunction (because like any subordinating conjunction, it shows the relationship between clauses).

I won`t leave her whatever happens.

This I more or less understood although I can`t quite get why Macmillan dictionary says that "whatever "can be both pronoun and conjunction while Lexico (Oxford) says that it can only be a pronoun...
But the real trouble is from now on!
In the sentence

Whatever decision he made I would support it.

"whatever" seems to function like a conjunction, but it`s placed before the noun just like a determiner. So, what is it here: determiner or conjunction? Or maybe even pronoun?
I don`t get it! Please, help me.

Greybeard · Answer

Pronoun: 1880   M. Oliphant He that will Not xxiii   Whatever can you want to emigrate for?
Pronoun: As nominal relative, in a generalized or indefinite sense: 1883   D. C. Murray Hearts i   We'll lay in whatever you want to-morrow.
Adverb: 1980   New Musical Express 12 Jan. 33/1   Whatever, the myth looks momentous in its sleek new American threads.
Noun: 2001   Jerusalem Post (Electronic ed.) 23 Feb. 7   I drove down there..and bought..this stuff. It contains seven different whatevers. On the package it said ‘Good for peace in the home against evil eye and all kinds of disturbances and fear’.
Adjective: 1884   Marshall's Tennis Cuts 94   That a player using a racket had no chance whatever against an opponent catching and throwing the ball.
Determiner: 1906   H. Belloc Hills & Sea 176   In whatever place a man may be the spring will come to him.

LPH · Answer

Whatever decision he made I would support it.

The parsing of this sentence corresponds well to a case analysed in CoGEL, except for a small difference which amounts to the use of an article. That is, the analysis would be perfectly right if the sentence were written as follows.

Whatever the decision he made I would support it.

Therefore, I'll still provide this explanation, as it is closely connected.
In this sentence "Whatever the decision he made"  is termed universal conditional-concessive clause and "whatever" is a subordinator (CoGEL 14.20 p. 1006). It is called universal because the wh-word implies a totality; the other type (alternative conditional-concessive) is introduced by "whether … or" or "or". The reason for combining "conditional" with "concessive" is that it is found that in this context there is overlap between the two ideas. (CoGEL 15.41, pp. 1099-1100)
It is a little tricky as a verb is omitted. The sentence without ellipsis, which is usable too, could read as follows.

Whatever would be the decision (that) he made I would support it.

The concessive implication comes through inferences such as "even if a decision had been less than good I would have supported it".

(CoGEL 15.42, pp. 1001-1002)
Note The verb "be" can be omitted from a universal clause if the subject of an SVC clause is an abstract noun phrase:
Whatever your problems (are/may be), they can't be worse than mine.

Whatever: pronoun, conjunction or determiner?

2 Answers

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question