TransWikia.com

What is a role of 'how' in 'How so many people' : [how][so many people] or [how so many people]?

English Language & Usage Asked by Mcreaper on March 2, 2021

I realize how so many people don’t have those simple things that we so much take for granted.

"how so many people don’t have those simple things that we so much take for granted" is an object of ‘realize’ and a wh-clause.

Q1
What’s the role of ‘how’? When we parse this clause, what is a subject of the wh-clause?

  1. [how so many people]? If this is right, ‘how’ may be a modifier of ‘many’. As a result, [how so many people] is a subject of the clause and at the same time, a conjunction of the wh-clause.
  2. [so many people]? If this is right, ‘how’ does not belong to the NP, [so many people] and just takes a role of conjunction alone.

Q2
Which meaning does ‘how’ in the clause come under when referring to macmillandictionary?

  1. #2 used for asking or saying what quantity, distance, age etc something is, or to what degree something is true
  2. #5 used for referring to a particular fact that you want to mention
    In this meaning, ‘how’ is used like ‘that’.

One Answer

How so many sentences hide their subject?

Like much of spoken English even the written word is increasingly casual. This is a shortened version of the sentence;

"How is it that so many people don't have those simple things?"

Which is still a shorter form of;

"How is it the case that so many people don't have those simple things?"

With this expansion you may be able to diagram more completely. Here I think that The Case is the subject and the rest should follow with little trouble.

Answered by Elliot on March 2, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP