TransWikia.com

We don't use any helping verb after "as soon as" but we use hv after no sooner at first in a sentence, so what is the sensible reason behind it

English Language & Usage Asked by Ajay Vyas on April 5, 2021

I have a question in mind since 2 years and even now I don’t get a satisfied answer because nobody wants to think it deeply but now I hope you will who is reading my note
My question is-
(1) as soon as I reached the station the train left
(2) no sooner did I reached the station the train left.
In the first sentence we don’t use any hv after “as soon as”
But in the 2nd we used why

One Answer

English has a sort of construction where a negative adverb modifies the clause, and triggers "verb-second" word order. What that means is this: That adverb goes at the start of the clause where the subject would normally go; and the verb goes second. Questions with a wh- word trigger verb-second word order, too. So: negative sentences:

1a. No sooner had I reached the station than the train left.

1b. Never have I seen such a thing before.

1c. Nowhere is this more common than...

Questions (I give these to give another context with verb-second word order.)

2a. When did you reach the station?

2b. When have you seen such a thing before?

2c. Where is this most common?

Verb-second word order can also be triggered by some adverbs which aren't actually negative but have some negative aspect in what they mean. For example, seldom. But it doesn't happen with positive adverbs unless the writer's being old-fashioned or poetic (Often have I...).

Answered by Rosie F on April 5, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP