TransWikia.com

Using a question mark mid-sentence

English Language & Usage Asked by Jeremy Stein on February 24, 2021

May I use a question mark in the middle of a sentence?

Examples:

Would you like the drapes to be white? or perhaps something off-white?

Would you like the logo to be centered? at the bottom? left off entirely?

7 Answers

I've mainly seen these in older literature, usually used in dialogue, but sometimes in rhetorical essays. It is rare in common and modern writing. I'd advise against it.

You should either capitalize or rephrase/repunctuate:

Would you like the drapes to be white? Or perhaps something off-white?

Would you like the logo to be centered? At the bottom? Left off entirely?

Or:

Would you like the drapes to be white; or perhaps something off-white?

Would you like the logo to be centered or at the bottom? Should it be left off entirely?

The former change (capitalizing) is more informal than the latter suggestion; also, the latter can be legitimately tweaked in several places based on context.

Correct answer by Daniel on February 24, 2021

In general, the question mark serves as an "end of sentence" marker. So in these example questions, the first letter of the next word should be capitalised, because they start new sentences.

Answered by FumbleFingers on February 24, 2021

I often see this in exercises in elementary mathematics textbooks. First it asks a question, then adds some variants afterward that are only fragments:

Farmer Jones has a horse pen that is 12 meters by 10 meters. What is the area of the pen? the perimeter? the width?

Answered by GEdgar on February 24, 2021

I believe in these cases the question mark is closest in function to a semi-colon. If you know what I mean when I say this, then feel free to use it with the same sensitivity as you do with a semi-colon (and ignore Kurt Vonnegut, he's so hipster it hurts). A sort of pause: "would rather the curtains be red? or some other colour?"

If you don't feel confident in using a semi-colon properly, then perhaps it's best to ignore it and stick to the most general usage, which is like that of a full stop.

Answered by Swizzlr on February 24, 2021

This is very informal in modern grammar. In a context where grammar is unimportant such as blogs, memo's, text messages, etc... then this is fine. (Please note that I'm not implying that all blogs, memos, txt's are not unimportant)

In Tweets, this can be helpful to save space but convey the right meaning.

Answered by Rikon on February 24, 2021

When trying to figure if you should use the question mark in the middle of the sentence, the best way is to say it out and see if it makes sense or sound correct. Most of the times this can be very helpful. The sentence "Would you like the drapes to be white? Or perhaps something off-white?" sounds continuous therefore you would simply write "Would you like the drapes to be white Or perhaps something off-white?". one of the punctuation rules is that when you use or you don't add a comma before it.

Answered by GoldenDragon on February 24, 2021

I randomly picked some old books and found examples in every one:

From The Way of the World by William Congreve, 1700:

Right, lady; I am Sir Wilfull Witwoud, so I write myself; no offence to anybody, I hope? and nephew to the Lady Wishfort of this mansion.

From History of Tom Jones, a Foundling by Henry Fielding, 1749:

Nay, I will venture to go farther, it is being in some degree epicures: for what could the greatest epicure wish rather than to eat with many mouths instead of one? which I think may be predicated of any one who knows that the bread of many is owing to his own largesses.

From School for Scandal by Richard Brinsley Sheridan, 1777:

O Fie--Sir Peter--would you have ME join in so mean a Trick? to trepan my Brother too?

From The Three Musketeers by Alexandre Dumas, 1844:

"How? know you again? Did you ever see that man before?"

From Marvels of Pond-life, by Henry J. Slack, 1861:

What are they? animals or vegetables? or something betwixt and between?

It was quite common in the 18th century books, less so in in the 19th century. Perhaps now that it's the 21st century, it's time to die out, but I kind of like it. It feels like a link to the past, an archaic but valid use of the symbol.

Oh mid-sentence question mark! Will you die out? with none to resurrect your use?

Answered by Jeremy Stein on February 24, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP