TransWikia.com

Usage of its or their with the group entity

English Language & Usage Asked by Gaurav Dave on August 4, 2020

I am confused between below sentences. I am not sure which one is grammatically correct. Online grammar checking tools such as “grammarly” are not showing any issue with all below sentences.

1 – Nowadays, the urban population is facing many hurdles in their daily lives.

2 – Nowadays, the urban population is facing many hurdles in its daily life.

3 – Nowadays, the urban population are facing many hurdles in their daily lives.

4 – Nowadays, the urban population are facing many hurdles in its daily life.

2 Answers

First of all, these sentences are all grammatically well formed. "Urban population" is a collective noun, and therefore can be either singular or plural. Using it as a singular noun will emphasize the characteristics of the group as a whole. Using it as a plural noun will emphasize the characteristics of the individuals in the group.

Given the context, which is the daily lives of people living in cities, I would say that Nos. 1 and 3 make the most sense. In other words, each member of the urban population has an individual daily life. Of course, in an abstract sense, all the things that happen to everyone in the urban population in the course of the day form a collective daily life, so I would be reluctant to say that Nos. 2 and 4 are wrong, because they are not.

Consider, however, that if you say that the urban population is shrinking, it would most likely be understood to mean that there are fewer people living in the city than ever before. On the other hand, if you say that the urban population are shrinking, someone could take it to mean that people living in the city are not as tall as they once were.

Answered by Steven Venti on August 4, 2020

You are neglecting to consider humanity's base instinct to anthropomorphize inanimate objects.

Nowadays, the urban population is facing many hurdles in its daily life.

When you use its you are consciously or unconsciously distancing yourself from the subject in that sentence.

Nowadays, the urban population is facing many hurdles in their daily lives.

The their attempts an association at a 'collective whole' (possibly embracing it) which may or may not include yourself but certainly one you recognize.

Answered by user150753 on August 4, 2020

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP