English Language & Usage Asked by gorudo on January 6, 2021
Today I’d like to present my question about the passablity of what I’ll post below.
Just as I talked with my american friends(I am Japanese) on discord, a certain person said to me;
Are romantic relationships more abnormal than not for Japanese in their 20s?
The context is to mock Japanese low birthrate and low marriage rate.
Anyway, I got a bit confused because by him using a single “not”, I couldn’t tell what he really meant.
With “not”, we can associate the sentence with two senses or more; “not romantic relationship” or “not abnormal”.
According to the speaker, it means the latter.
Thus I think that “more/less X than not” means “more/less X than not X”.
The idiom, “More often than not”, “More likely than not” can be interpreted through this structure.
Do you think this structure has common passablity?; That is, can I adapt this as I please, like “more brilliant than not”, “more famous than not”, “more easy than not”.
I think this structure can be better off if it is used in question sentences.
Any thought?
It clearly does mean more abnormal than not abnormal - and it is certainly idiomatic English.
However I personally would not have used it in that type of context, because it sounds rather absurd to say someone is more abnormal than they are not abnormal. And it is similar with "more brilliant/famous/easy than not".
These are "gradable" adjectives, which are possessed by their subjects in varying degrees. And "more xxxx than not" is not a very descriptive way of explaining degree.
More aptly one could say that someone was "not very romantic", "above/below average in their romantic inclination" or express it in 101 other different ways.
Answered by WS2 on January 6, 2021
Yeah, it's a neat shortcut for saying "51% or more X". And like the other answer states, the sentence you quote is a bit tortured - it's not the clearest writing. One reason is because of the "double negative", something we try to avoid. I had to pause for a moment to figure out what its author meant. And yes, also, it's sometimes said in an ironic way. Although, "more often than not" is just fine and common. It's a longer way of talking, so it goes well with a beer in one hand and a pool cue in the other.
Answered by Johnny on January 6, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP