English Language & Usage Asked by JakobWAD on August 16, 2021
Just got the comment from a co-worker that we shouldn’t repeat the word ‘maker’ in the following enumeration:
A unique learning experience for senior executives, decision makers
and policy makers.
My gut feeling tells me this is the correct way to write it, but I’m not a native English speaker, so your advice would be greatly appreciated!
Thank you!
Both ways are grammatically correct, and this seems to be a matter of style. It seems that it's important to consider whether it's written text (e-mail, ad prospect) or a speech in front of the audience.
In the latter case you might want to try both variants and achieve different effects. Saying 'decision and policy makers' with large emphasis on 'and' might break the monotony. But if you want to achieve the monotony and strict symmetry the original phrasing is good.
Answered by alexsms on August 16, 2021
Your original phrasing
senior executives, decision makers and policy makers
is correct. If it's desired to state "makers" only once, then "decision and policy" is a list of two items which needs an "and" before its last item; thus "decision and policy makers". This in turn is the second item in a list of two; this list needs an "and" before its last item. So we get
senior executives and decision and policy makers
Both "ands" are needed. If you'd written
senior executives, decision and policy makers
then the reader would have parsed the "and" as part of the item "decision and policy makers". This results in two items with just a comma between them and no "and". Because there is no "and", the reader would thus expect at least one further item (with an "and" before the last item).
Answered by Rosie F on August 16, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP