TransWikia.com

Primary and secondary stress in IPA transcriptions on Cambridge Dictionary when two words are involved

English Language & Usage Asked by David Robert Jones on July 7, 2021

I am trying to understand IPA transcriptions in https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/ when two words are involved. In particular, their rationale for changing some stresses, compared to the stresses in the independent transcriptions, when the words are put together.

For example, roller skate was transcribed as /ˈroʊ.lɚ skeɪt/. There is a space between "ˈroʊ.lɚ" and "skeɪt", and roller and skate were independently transcribed as /ˈroʊ.lɚ/ and /skeɪt/ respectively. This is intuitive to me: first word + space + second word.

rubber band on the other hand, was transcribed as /ˌrʌb.ɚ ˈbænd/. However, rubber and band were independently transcribed as /ˈrʌb.ɚ/ and /bænd/ respectively.

Finally, safety pin was transcribed as /ˈseɪf.ti ˌpɪn/. However, safety and pin were independently transcribed as /ˈseɪf.ti/ and /pɪn/ respectively.

Why the transcriptions are not always first word + space + second word, where first word and second word are the independent transcriptions, such as in the first example? Why the stresses changed in the transcriptions?

One Answer

TLDR: The stresses are changed because this is how native English speakers actually pronounce them (except for the case of roller skate, which I suspect is a typo).

If you have a one-syllable word, it usually has primary stress on that syllable (except when it's a function word, in which case it may not), so Cambridge dictionary doesn't bother to put stress in its IPA for skate, pin, and band.

When you put two words together to form a compound noun, the stress can change. If it's treated as a compound noun, it should not have more than one syllable with primary stress. The primary stress will almost always fall on a syllable which has primary stress in one of the two original words, most often the first word, but not always.

For example, in safety pin the stress falls on the first syllable: /ˈseɪf.ti ˌpɪn/. In rubber band, the stress falls on the last syllable: /ˌrʌb.ɚ ˈbænd/. And in journeyman, there is no stress on man: /ˈdʒɝː.ni.mən/. These seem to be precisely parallel situations, so why do they behave that way? I don't know. But I am an American, and this is the way I actually pronounce these three words.

Personally, I would put secondary stress on skate in roller skate. I don't know why Cambridge Dictionary doesn't; the two pronunciations they give (US and UK) actually do. Maybe there's variation among native English speakers, but I think that it's likely to be a typo.

Correct answer by Peter Shor on July 7, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP