present perfect + past simple in the same sentence

Question

Can I use present perfect tense and simple past tense in the same sentence ?

For example :

Even though I have just/recently cleaned  up the house, I spotted some bugs around the kitchen (today/this evening).

Is this sentence grammatically correct and idiomatic as well?

WS2 · Accepted Answer

Yes, it is perfectly idiomatic since the perfect and the past tenses relate to different time conditions.
Although he has watched football all his life, he didn't go to today's match.
The first verb relates to something that has been going on throughout the subject's lifetime, the second to what he did today.

Anirudha Sarkar · Answer

The 1st part of the sentence is correct but the 2nd part is erroneous because when we talk of today (which is not yet over) we are talking in the present contest, hence present perfect tense should be used. The correct sentence is "Although he has watched football all his life, he hasn't seen today's match."

Answered by Anirudha Sarkar on October 5, 2021

user387458 · Answer

Yes, it is perfectly idiomatic since the perfect and the past tenses relate to different time conditions.

Although he has watched football all his life, he didn't go to today's match.

The first verb relates to something that has been going on throughout the subject's lifetime, the second to what he did today.

present perfect + past simple in the same sentence

3 Answers

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question