Preposition usage: "Envious at" vs "Envious of"

Question

Under what circumstances are these two prepositions used in a grammatically precise manner? I posed this question because a grammar-editing application marked the indiscriminate interchangeable usage of these phrases as being grammatically correct.
I would imagine that these following examples are correct:

"I'm envious of how flawlessly you played the piano."

"I'm envious at the mere thought of your flawless playing."

However, the aforementioned application (Grammarly) found the sentence "I'm envious at how flawlessly you played the piano," to be faultless.  So, which of the above usages is correct?
(I've also searched the site for this question and I have not seen any duplicates, despite there being similar questions.)

BoldBen · Accepted Answer

In your examples 'envious of' is used before a characteristic or possession the other person has. This is the same as "I'm envious of your car" or "He's envious of their success". This is the most common use of the word 'envy'.
'Envious at', however, precedes 'at the thought of' and the thought is not the source of your envy, it's an event, related to the source, which has triggered the envy.
'Envious at' can also be used with 'sight', 'sound' and other words describing trigger points. For example "I was envious at the sight of Raj driving his new Porche", "Alan was envious at the sound of Bella's virtuoso piano playing" or even "Clarissa was envious at the feel of Deborah's cashmere cardigan"
In summary 'envious at' relates to events or other stimuli which trigger envy whereas 'envious of' relates to the object, condition or possession which is the source of the envy. A rare case of a grammar checker picking up a subtle error correctly!

Preposition usage: "Envious at" vs "Envious of"

One Answer

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question