TransWikia.com

Not~but~ construction

English Language & Usage Asked on March 25, 2021

Grammatically, is structure "not + preposition + but + preposition + object" possible?

For example, can I say ‘someone is lying not on but off the couch’? I mean ‘someone is lying not on the couch but off the couch on the floor.’

In my native language, not only ‘someone is lying not on but off the couch’ but also ‘someone is lying not on the couch but off the couch’ is wrong, so I wonder if it’s possible in English.

2 Answers

Grammatically, is structure "not + preposition + but + preposition + object" possible?

Yes, it is.

For example, can I say 'someone is lying not on but off the couch'? I mean 'someone is lying not on the couch but off the couch on the floor.'

No, you can't, but this is mainly because "off" does not function in the way that would be required to make that particular sentence idiomatic.

In other Germanic languages, there is usually a separate word for this particular form of "but" - English lacks it.

This form of "but" = however, on the contrary;

The OED gives

But (conj.) III. In a compound sentence, connecting the two coordinate clauses; or introducing an independent sentence connected in sense, though not in form, with the preceding sentence. In a compound sentence the second clause may be contracted so as to omit constituents also occurring in the main clause, e.g. ... John couldn't come to see me, but Mary could = ‘John couldn't come to see me, but Mary could come to see me’.

Thus "He did not put the gun in the desk but on the desk."

thus

"He did not put the gun in the desk however, on the contrary, he put the gun on the desk."

Correct answer by Greybeard on March 25, 2021

As others have said, off the couch is not really idiomatic, but for example under the couch would be, so I will take your sentence to be

Someone is lying not on but under the couch.

This type of coordination construction, which is not special to the coordination of preposition phrases, is usually called 'right node raising' (RNR), though CGEL prefers to call it 'delayed right constituent coordination'.

Using basic coordination, your sentence would read

Someone is lying not on the couch but under it.

Discussion

RNR is famous in linguistics because it 'is a phenomenon that challenges theories of syntax in significant ways.' CGEL introduces it as follows (p. 1343):

In this construction the constituent which in basic coordination would appear as the rightmost element of the first coordinate is held back until after the final coordinate:

[21]  i  She knew of my other work but never mentioned it.               [basic coordination]
        ii  She knew of but never mentioned my other work.       [delayed right constituent]

In general, the effect is to heighten the contrast between the coordinates by removing from them material that would be the same in each. But the construction is appreciably more difficult to process than basic coordination, both for the addressee, who has to hold the first coordinate in mind until the sense is completed at the end, and for the speaker, who has to plan ahead to ensure that each coordinate ends in a way that syntactically allows completion by the delayed element - as knew of and never mentioned both allow completion by an NP complement.66 Characteristically, there is a prosodic break after the final coordinate, signalling that the element that follows relates to the whole coordination, not just to the final coordinate.

66Examples are found where this condition is not satisfied. One case is illustrated in ?I always have and always will value her advice, where the plain form value is an admissible continuation of will but not of have: compare basic I have always valued her advice and always will value it. Another involves coordination of comparisons of equality and inequality: ?It's as good or better than the official version, where as good takes a complement headed by as not than. Such examples are not fully grammatical and would generally be avoided in monitored speech and writing; the second can be corrected to It's as good as or better than the official version.

In your case, the constituent that is 'held back' is the noun phrase the couch.

Answered by linguisticturn on March 25, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP