English Language & Usage Asked on February 8, 2021
Is it allowed to have multiple hyphens in one word? I want to use the word semi-self-sustaining in the sentence
However, the ability to produce semi-self-sustaining stations is
possessed by up to a quarter of all nations.
Should we use semi-selfsustaining or avoid it by using partially self-sustaining?
In ‘The Penguin Guide to Punctuation’, R L Trask identifies three cases in which a hyphen is required after a prefix. One of them is where a prefix is added to a word which already contains a hyphen. His examples are non-bribe-taking politicians, his pre-globe-trotting days, non-stress-timed languages and an un-re-elected politician.
In your example, self-sustaining is a word which already contains a hyphen and to which you wish to add the prefix semi-. The resulting semi-self-sustaining is consistent with Trask’s advice.
Answered by Barrie England on February 8, 2021
I don't personally think that using multiple hyphens is a general problem. I have often seen words like "four-year-old" and the like to make an example.
Since self-sustaining is written with a hyphen, I would go for semi-self-sustaining.
Answered by Besi on February 8, 2021
The Chicago Manual of Style, sixteenth edition (2010) glancingly affirms the advice that Barrie England cites from The Penguin Guide to Punctuation in his answer:
6.80 En dashes with compound adjectives. ...
A single word or prefix should be joined to a hyphenated compound by another hyphen rather than an en dash; if the result is awkward, reword.
non-English-speaking peoples
a two-thirds-full cup (or, better, a cup that is to-thirds full)
As Chicago very wisely observes, the critical question to ask in deciding whether to use multiple hyphens in a compound word is a highly subjective one: Does the result seem awkward? If it does, your best bet is to reword to avoid the awkwardness—not to press on in unthinking obedience to some set-in-stone rule about proper punctuation, regardless of the effect it has on the sentence you're trying to construct.
Answered by Sven Yargs on February 8, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Answers
Recent Questions
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP