TransWikia.com

Is this sentence of Vitalik Buterin correct?

English Language & Usage Asked on December 31, 2020

I was reading A Philosophy of Blockchain Validation of Vitalik Buterin. The following sentence strikes me as odd:

Data availability checks do rely on a very conservative assumption that there exists at least some small number of honest nodes somewhere in the network continues to apply, though the good news is that this minimum honesty threshold is low, and does not grow even if there is a very large number of attackers.

I would humbly restate the sentence in the following manner:

Data availability checks do rely on a very conservative assumption continuing to apply, namely that there exists at least some small number of honest nodes somewhere in the network, though the good news is that this minimum honesty threshold is low, and does not grow even if there is a very large number of attackers.

or would make it even more concise:

Data availability checks do rely on a very conservative assumption that there exists at least some small number of honest nodes somewhere in the network, though the good news is that this minimum honesty threshold is low, and does not grow even if there is a very large number of attackers.

Is Buterin’s sentence correct? If not, what is not correct in it? Do my attempts of correcting the sentence make sense to y’all?

P.S. This is not a proofreading request. The relevant text was published five weeks prior to this question.

One Answer

Buterin’s original is incorrect. “... network applies ...” should say “... network that applies ...”, with “that” referring to the previously mentioned assumption.

Your final version seems the best. It removes the redundant and unnecessary “continues to apply”, which adds nothing to the stated reliance on an existing assumption.

The only modification I suggest is to remove “do”, which is not needed. Its only function is to place a little emphasis on the reliance, and I doubt that that emphasis is needed.

Correct answer by Anton on December 31, 2020

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP