English Language & Usage Asked by Brendan Anthony on July 29, 2020
I heard this on TV (in reference to a Trump rally), but although it “sounds” all right, it doesn’t seem to be grammatically correct since “group” is the subject.
There was a group of people who were enjoying it.
Wouldn’t the correct way instead be as follows?
There was a group of people who was enjoying it.
It seems technically better, but to my ears the double usage of “was” almost makes it sound worse.
If you want enjoying to apply to the group as a whole, you have to use that rather than who.
There was a group of people that was enjoying it.
When you use who, it refers to people, which is plural, so it needs a plural verb. Switching to that changes the reference to group, which is singular.
You can also say:
There was a group of people that were enjoying it.
There is a very subtle difference, I believe. The first emphasizes that the group as a whole is enjoying it. The second emphasizes that a number of people are enjoying it, and then defines the group in terms of those people.
Answered by Barmar on July 29, 2020
Whenever I get stuck into such a situation, I think of my mother tongue (Urdu_Pakistan). It gives me two senses, both of them seem true and do not sound ambiguous to me. I think whether it is 'was' or 'were', it depends upon you what you want to get out of it.
Answered by Asad Sultan on July 29, 2020
Question: What is correct in the following example? Who or that?
one group who will conduct the experiment or one group that will conduct the experiment
Answered by user393123 on July 29, 2020
..............There...............was... {a group of people who were enjoying it.}
Adverb(complement)... verb......................... subject
Thus we have
There was a group {of [people who were enjoying it]}.
[people who were enjoying it] is a noun phrase made up of a noun (people) + relative clause (who were enjoying it).
{of [people who were enjoying it]} is a prepositional adjectival clause modifying "group"
Thus because the referent of "who" is "people", "were" is correct.
Answered by Greybeard on July 29, 2020
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP