TransWikia.com

Is the pronunciation change from "woman" to "women" unique in English?

English Language & Usage Asked by Jack Roy on August 20, 2021

Is “woman/women” the only English word group that undergoes a change – via conjugation, pluralization… whatever may be the cause – wherein a syllable of the polysyllabic word has spelling changes that do not have a significant change to its pronunciation (i.e. the “-man” and “-men” sound as “mun” in both cases), while simultaneously having another syllable that Does have a change in pronunciation, even though its spelling did not change (i.e. the “wom” pronounced as “woom” (or womb) and “wihm” (wim, whim) respectively)?

Mind you, “children” is not a correct answer because it begins as a (albeit, differently pronounced) single syllable/word and transforms into a polysyllabic word.

Edit: to clarify, I’m looking for specific words that follow the unusual pattern of the “woman/women” construct: a specific syllable changes pronunciation without a spelling change while another syllable changes spelling without a pronunciation change. One commenter @john Lawler pointed out the Umlaut factor in this word and sparked a notion to me that the answer might lie among German cognates, but in my life I’ve never found any words like this and that is why I ask the question. If you have evidence that this word group is not unique for this quality then please provide examples. Also, my curiosity is so piqued by Lawler’s suggestion that I would welcome even German words that do this as examples, though I’d request a translation and phonetic transcription with that, please.

2 Answers

In American English, woman is pronounced /'wʊmən/, and women is pronounced /'wɪmən/.
The only difference between them is the vowels in the first stressed syllable, /ʊ/ and /ɪ/.

/ʊ/ and /ɪ/ are very similar; they're both high lax vowels. The only difference between the two vowels is that singular /ʊ/ is a back high lax vowel and plural /ɪ/ is a front high lax vowel.

This situation -- having a back vowel in the singular and a front vowel in the plural --
is not at all unusual in English. It's the result of the old Germanic process of Umlaut,
which fronts vowels to anticipate front vowels in an ending. The same thing happened to
goose ~ geese, only with the high tense vowels /u/ and /i/, instead of high lax vowels.
Details in the link.

Answered by John Lawler on August 20, 2021

Normally the pronunciation of "woman" and "women" would almost be the same. So it is not so astonishing that the speakers differentiate the pronunciation of the plural regardless of the spelling. In this case it is not the logic of spelling that matters but the practical need of differentiation of two words that originally were too similar in pronunciation.

Answered by rogermue on August 20, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP