TransWikia.com

Is it correct to use the comparative adjective "blacker?"

English Language & Usage Asked by Bill Oakey on June 9, 2021

You can find bluer, redder, greener, and whiter in the dictionary, but not blacker. This seems mystifying.

In his “El Paso” song, Marty Robbins sang,

“Blacker than night were the eyes of Felina.”

During the recent Presidential campaign, some pundits asked,

“Is Mitt Romney blacker than Barack Obama?”

NASA has created a new nanotube material that is

“blacker than black paint,” according to various published reports.

There are several official shades of black, such as taupe and ebony, leading to the presumption that some shades are “blacker” than others.

Since “blacker” is not in the dictionary, would the proper usage be “more black”?

4 Answers

What dictionary are you using? With a quick online search, I see the word "blacker" in these:

Answered by Charles on June 9, 2021

The reason that some dictionaries do not contain "blacker" and "blackest" is that "black" is considered to be an absolute adjective. This is the same reason you are not supposed to say "more perfect", "more unique", "whiter", "deader", or "fuller". See, for example, this web page.

There are lots of people who do not abide by this "rule". For example, Shakespeare, Procol Harum and the writers of the United States Constitution.

Answered by Peter Shor on June 9, 2021

As technical terms, blackest and blacker are still going strong:

Acktar Black ™– world blackest coating – now 1% reflectance from FUV to FIR

World's blackest material unveiled

Blacker Than Black:

Black is black, right? Not so, according to a team of NASA engineers now developing a blacker-than pitch material that will help scientists gather hard-to-obtain scientific measurements or observe currently unseen astronomical objects, like Earth-sized planets in orbit around other stars. The nanotech-based material now being developed by a team of 10 technologists at the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Md., is a thin coating of multi-walled carbon nanotubes — tiny hollow tubes made of pure carbon about 10,000 times thinner than a strand of human hair.

Answered by Wayfaring Stranger on June 9, 2021

I used to see "Blacker" fairly frequently when film cameras were still the mainstay of photography.

Obtaining a "true black" was difficult with color negative film. So when a manufacturer would come out with a "new, improved" film they would often say, "Richer, more thoroughly saturated colors with whiter whites, and blacker blacks."

(What they used to call "white" and "black" fell short of the mark, and the new improved film achieves better results. But I would note, that then next generation of film might make the same claims all over again.)

Answered by Packard on June 9, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP