TransWikia.com

Is 'but rather' considered grammatically correct?

English Language & Usage Asked by Adam Mosheh on July 23, 2021

Is this comment that I made here grammatically correct?

In Latin, when a group of males and females is combined, the neutral plural form is not used, but rather the masculine is.

3 Answers

In:

In Latin, when a group of males and females is combined, the neutral plural form is not used, but rather the masculine is.

'but rather' is perfectly fine and a good alternative to:

In Latin, when a group of males and females is combined, the neutral plural form is not used; rather the masculine is.

'Rather' is like 'instead'; using 'but' allows it in one conjoined sentence rather than a separate one.

Correct answer by Mitch on July 23, 2021

Assuming you are referring to the clause "when a group of males and females is combined" then the answer is "Yes, it is correct." Because you are talking about a group (singular), the verb should be is. Were you to restate it: "when males and females is combined" it would, of course be wrong, and should be written: "when males and females are combined" because you are using a plural subject.

Answered by treehead on July 23, 2021

In response to what treehead asserted, the verb "combined" should be noted to be of great importance when revising the statement "In Latin, when a group of males and females is combined, the neutral plural form is not used, but rather the masculine is." The word "combined" is used to show that there are 2 or more things which are being brought together to create 1. Therefore, it would not be correct to say that a group(the already combined form) of two components(males and females) is combined. However, if "when a group of males and females is combined" is meant to refer to 'a group of males' and 'a group of females' being combined, the plural form 'are' should be used instead of the singular form 'is' due to the existence of there being 2 things. An object cannot combine with itself unless it were to disintegrate beforehand.

Answered by Alexander on July 23, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP