TransWikia.com

Identification of the simple subject in a sentence

English Language & Usage Asked on July 12, 2021

I am having trouble identifying the simple subject in this sentence:
One of the problems facing journalism today is false news and disinformation

I believe it is one. A friend of mine, however, is of the opinion that it ought to be journalism

One Answer

"Simple subject" is not a valid concept.

It means a single word that the teacher can point at. It isn't the subject, which are normally full noun phrases, with modifying determiners, adjectives, phrases, and clauses.

Everything that comes before 'is' in the example sentence is the subject of the sentence; it's a noun phrase with a modifying reduced relative clause.

Don't ask about the "simple subject" because it doesn't exist.

-John Lawler


In a now-deleted comment, Cascabel said...

..."journalism" here is part of a reduced relative clause modifying "problems" ....definitely not the entire subject; just part of the Noun Phrase.

If "journalism" were the actual subject, it could be read as...

"Journalism (today) is false news and disinformation",

which is possibly a true statement when applied to some news sources these days, but obviously not the intent of the writer.

To summarize...

Identifying a simple subject in a complicated sentence could be compared to applying Bohr's model of the atom to an E8 lattice structure.

Answered by Cascabel on July 12, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP