TransWikia.com

I don't know how to understand this sentence ' it seems inconceivable that at least one of these planets does not have a life form on it'

English Language & Usage Asked by Sakura tn on August 7, 2021

the full context is like this:

However,when we look at the 100 billion stars in our galaxy(the Milky Way),and 100 billion galaxies in the observable Universe,it seems inconceivable that at least one of these planets does not have a life form on it;in fact,the best educated guess we can make ,using the little we do know about the conditions for cabon-based life,leads us to estimate that perhaps one in 100,000 stars might have a life-bearing planet orbiting it.

someone says that ‘at least one of these planets does not have a life form on it’ means ‘no planet has a life form on it ‘, but I can’t understand why,to me, it means ‘more than one planet have no life on it’

2 Answers

The trick is inconceivable.

The fact is the phrase you, quite rightly, have trouble with is preceded by "inconceivable". This usage negates the phrase following. The phrase without the negative in front is clearly wrong since we on earth have a few forms of life and are not excluded in his enumerations.

A clearer version would be;

"It seems impossible that at least one of these planets does not have a life form on it" some of it intelligent.

Answered by Elliot on August 7, 2021

The writer failed to say what they meant. No wonder you have trouble understanding the sentence.

The idea the writer states is that because there are so many planets, one would think that at least one must have life on it. (The writer certainly doesn't go so far as to suggest that every one of those planets has life on it.)

As Elliot implied, after the words "It seems inconceivable" there comes the negation of that idea which the writer expects to think about all those planets. The trouble is that the writer hasn't correctly expressed the negation of that idea. The passage would be better phrased:

"... it seems inconceivable that none of these planets has a life form on it ..."

Answered by Rosie F on August 7, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP